JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Horror V Comedy

Admin

Deputy Head

Subject: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Horror V Comedy Thu Jul 31 2008, 13:41

JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Horror V Comedy

Judges: Elfie Dumbledore, Duck the duck and Raistlin the Wizard

Those who participated in this:

Ellemanae
Belldandy
violetriddle
kathrineee_anne
polly
Elana
skyla0305
Severus Snape

To judges:

Each participant needs to be marked out of 100 for their entry. How you mark them is up to you. Look at creativity, individuality and style as well as relevance, clothing and hair choice and background etc.

Look at models clothes, hair, pose and background
Also
look at the two shots together, making sure that not only do they fit
well with each of the opposites, but also sit well together

For
each person put their mark out of 50 for this category and write a few
things on what you thought was good and what could be improved (ie:
what they lost marks for)

Scores will go up when each judge has marked each participant. Scores will be an average of all three scores.

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Horror V Comedy Fri Aug 01 2008, 16:20

Ellemanae 75
Firstly I like how you have your horror shot holding the arm of your comedy shot - nice touch. Using the same colour in both styles work well, though the horror style is much more to my taste. The comedy shot does, however, work well for a fashion shoot though colouring in hair looses some marks here as it brings to much attention to just that one thing and doesnt seem to sit well.

Belldandy 56
I know that comedy was a large part though your expression just doesnt show this - more a horror expression from a cheesy horror film. Like the model before you, your horror one is much better than your comedy shot. I can not see any comedy in this other one at all even though style works well with both shots as a whole.

violetriddle 58
Which one is the horror and which one is the comedy here? Your first shot, though well styled and presented, doesnt seem to show any of the chosen genres. Your second shot is unusual and not one you would expect to see in a fashion competition though I like your daring here so its points from me for that.

kathrineee_anne 30
A 'blood thirsty power hungry' model who wears a crucifix and likes animals? Im sorry but this really does not show this at all. Your comedy shot also doesnt really sit well in this category either, and none, I am afraid, show style for a fashion competition.

polly 76
I had to look at this twice because at first I really wasnt sure whether I liked it or not. Your horror shot is really elegant though with the good portraya of what I was expecting and your comedy shot, although completely not my taste in style, actually works well in this shot (which I am surprising myself at saying it!).

Elana 42
If this combined shot was for a carnival shoot out then you would have got top marks. Unfortunately this was for horror and comedy and I dont really see it from this at all. Style wise they are great, genre matching they are not.

skyla0305 65
Interesting. They are well combined in this shot and stand alone to an average degree. The horror would perhaps get top marks if it wasnt for that horried mask covering your face. A model needs to show her face as it is a big selling point. As for the comedy side it works well matching into the scene, though not quite right for my liking.

Severus Snape 70
I am nearly in stitches laughing here. You have the comedy down to a tee, though together these show more comedy than horror. It is cleverly done how you show the same but different though your hair stylist needs to be shot on your horror pose! A good try by all means though not enough horror residing here.

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Horror V Comedy Thu Aug 07 2008, 16:12

Horrified of the outfits vs Dieing of laughter due to your scores (Aka Marking)

Ellemanae - 45
Waits for the laugh to come...

Belldandy - 85
Nice touch, the model throwing her tongue!

violetriddle - 45
Description says all...

k-anne - 45
Im am not impressed...

polly - 65
Im having mixed feelings, the horror dress is great but no one deserves whatever that thing is on their hair.

Elana - 65
Excellent shots and clothes but... where's the horror?

skyla0305 - 60
Will no one make me laugh?

Severus Snape - 85
you're a lucky person! That squeleton model reminded me of achmed the dead terrorrist which made me laugh!

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Horror V Comedy Mon Aug 11 2008, 12:46

Due to our third judge being away on holiday, we
have asked a third party to score for the third judge. Please note that
they are simply scoring with no comments. These will be averages with
mine and rais scores.

There scores are as follows;

Ellemanae 78
Belldandy 58
violetriddle 55
kathrineee_anne 58
polly 82
Elana 60
skyla0305 82
Severus Snape 93

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Horror V Comedy Mon Aug 11 2008, 12:52

Your final averaged scores are as follows

Severus Snape 70, 85, 93 (83)

polly 76, 65, 82 (75)

skyla0305 65, 60, 82 (69)

Belldandy 56, 85, 58 (67)

Ellemanae 75, 45, 78 (66)

Elana 42, 65, 60 (56)
violetriddle 58, 45, 55 (53)

kathrineee_anne 30, 45, 58
(45)

» NTM - ROUND 5 - PART 2 : OPPOSITES : Horror V Comedy
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 4 : Air
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 2 - Temperance
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 2 - Charity
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 2 - Diligence