JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Night V Day

Admin

Deputy Head

Subject: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Night V Day Thu Jul 31 2008, 13:44

JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Night V Day
Judges: Elfie Dumbledore, Duck the duck and Raistlin the Wizard

Those who participated in this:

Belldandy
Ellemanae
violetriddle
polly
Elana
skyla0305
kathrineee_anne
Severus Snape

To judges:

Each participant needs to be marked out of 100 for their entry. How you mark them is up to you. Look at creativity, individuality and style as well as relevance, clothing and hair choice and background etc.

Look at models clothes, hair, pose and background
Also
look at the two shots together, making sure that not only do they fit
well with each of the opposites, but also sit well together

For
each person put their mark out of 50 for this category and write a few
things on what you thought was good and what could be improved (ie:
what they lost marks for)

Scores will go up when each judge has marked each participant. Scores will be an average of all three scores.

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Night V Day Fri Aug 01 2008, 16:41

Belldandy 95
I like how you have interpeted this category with colour and also shown a relation between the two poses. The yellow jacket on the day model is a great touch for sunlight and both styles are well thought out. The only negative here is the lack of facial expression changing. Well done.

Ellemanae 92
Another interesting take on this category, though unlike the model before you, you have chosen the direct way to show this and also kept with modelling. Both shots are well done and have been merged really well here. Well done.

violetriddle 80
Although styles are well chosen and go well together, there is a lack of energy in the shots. It seems too minimalistic for my liking, though this isnt a huge negative by any means. Like the first model, facial expression doesnt change which is a shame.

polly 80
A here I see night time taken to the literal. The pose for night in itself is too stiff and not quite a models style, though works well. Day time shot better, though facial expressions again are the same. A little too minimalistic here also.

Elana 75
We have a mixture of concepts here that I can see which is a little off putting. The day time model seems to be showing more symbolism with sunlight colour, unless I am confused and that is night time, though I beieve if it is it doesnt work that way. The night time shot is being portrayed more literally which put together does not show night V day well. On their own, style is good, though.

skyla0305 76
Im usually a great fan of purpe but your night time shot purple contacts just seems unecessary. Other than this, this shot is much better than the day shot as I feel that this is too stiff a pose. Not quite up to your standards here I feel.

kathrineee_anne 86
A complete oposite shown here and done rather well. It doesnt automatically show night V day, though it does work very well together as one person. Night style is beautiful - no complaints at the style here from me and day style works really well too. Lack of expression change lets you down here though.

Severus Snape 89
Oh dear, you have been polishing your head again havent you?! The complete baldness here with that shine is so offputting. As with the first model, you show great concept and relation between both shots, although day model looks slightly bored, and Im sorry i just cant see past that head shine!

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Night V Day Thu Aug 07 2008, 15:57

Awful vs Dreadful = Your Scores (aka Marking)

Belldandy - 85
Nice Wings. Even though the outfits are good the choice was too obvious, you should have dared more.

Ellemeane - 80
Even though im not a fan of the outfits the interpretation was more out of the box so you get extra points for that.

violetriddle - 65
You see that yellow flower in the hair? I shall not say more your score speaks for itself.

polly - 80
Thumbs up! very good. not brilliant but very good!

Elana - 60
Hmmm I think a description would have been good in here.

skyla0305 - 90
Nice outfits!

kathrinee_anne - 75
Nice transformation!

Severus Snape - 84
This is like the first models. Too obvious and though I usually appreciate these kind of outfits today's clothes are not so impressive as usual.

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Night V Day Mon Aug 11 2008, 12:57

Due to our third judge being away on holiday, we
have asked a third party to score for the third judge. Please note that
they are simply scoring with no comments. These will be averages with
mine and rais scores.

There scores are as follows;

Belldandy 90
Ellemanae 86
violetriddle 78
polly 80
Elana 83
skyla0305 80
kathrineee_anne 80
Severus Snape 76

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Night V Day Mon Aug 11 2008, 13:02

Your final section scores are as follows;

Belldandy 95, 85, 90 (90)
Ellemanae 92, 80, 86 (86)

Severus Snape 89, 84, 76 (83)

skyla0305 76, 90, 80 (82)

kathrineee_anne 86, 75, 80
(81)

polly 80, 80, 80 (80)
violetriddle 80, 65, 78 (75)
Elana 75, 60, 83 (73)

» JUDGES THREAD : Round 4 : Air
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 1 - Greed
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 1 - Sloth
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 1 - Wrath
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 1 - Envy