Graphics Tournament - Round 1 - Disney Heroes - Voting

The first challenge of the tournament is to create a graphic on a Disney hero. You can pick any hero, including princesses, from any Disney movie. This is not limited to animated Disney films, a list of all movies can be found here.

Your graphic should be blend size; anything above 400x400, but no larger than 800x600. They should contain the name of the hero and the film with any other text you wish.

You have a month to submit the graphics to amberg93, via PM before the rounds will be put up to vote.

Please upload them to a photo host which will not identify you, such as imageshack, tinypic or servimg (not photobucket).

Voting Procedure

1. Look at each of the graphics below. Take your time looking over the graphics.

2. Score each graphic with a mark out of ten (make sure you take your likeness of the graphic in tact as well):

10 -- Score 10 for a beautifully made graphic with no flaws that you can see and follows all specifications.
9
8
7 -- Score 7 and above for a very good graphic with few flaws that are visible and follows all specifications.
6
5 -- Score 5 and above for a good graphic that could be improved, with minor flaws, and/or does not follow all specifications.
4
3 -- Score 3 and above for an okay graphic that has more than a couple visible flaws and/or does not follow all specifications.
2
1-- Score 1 and above for a poor graphic, that you feel has no redeeming qualities and follows no specifications.

NOTE: If a graphic doesn't follow all of the specifications, it is not able to receive more than a 5 no matter the vote received.

3. These graphics haven't been changed at all, what you see is what was sent.

4. Once all scores are in I will work out the averages. Please make sure you score ALL graphics otherwise scores will get skewed.

5. Obviously, don't score your own! Participants should PM me their scores, non-participants can post them in this thread, or PM them if they'd rather.

6. Participants and non-participants will earn 50 housepoints for voting (as it *is* quite a bit of work!) Participants who submitted graphics for the round and do not vote will lose 30 points.

7. Please vote fairly, and mark each vote clearly. No comments about the graphics needed (though appreciated, so long as they are constructive).

Any questions about voting, please ask me! Graphics will be in the next post.

Graphic 1:


Graphic 2:


Graphic 3:


Graphic 4:


Graphic 5:


Graphic 6:


Graphic 7:

Graphic 1: 5/10
I think you can see afew flaws, like how Ariel is not blurred well enough, you know? Also, the colour contrast (... is that the right term? xD) between the blue-ish background and Ariel isn't exactly in my taste.

Graphic 2: 9/10
My favourite thing is the frame and colour of it I would've handed out a perfect 10, if I hadn't found ONE major flaw; it's Captain Jack Sparrow xD

Graphic 3: 4/10
It looks a bit sloppy, and just... well, never been a fan of disco, really.

Graphic 4: 4/10
It looks as if someone just slammed on some pictures, faded them a bit, and added the text in a nice font.

Graphic 5: 8/10
SPARRABETH!!!!!! ...anyway. Captain Jack Sparrow's sword annoys me to bits. Actually, now when I think of it, the entire Jack (the right one) looks a bit... well, off. It looks as if it's not entirely finished around the edges.

Graphic 6: 8/10
I think there's a nice balance with the colours It doesn't look too messy, or too sloppily done.

Graphic 7: 10/10
I can't find anything wrong with it, really :D

Graphic 1: 10/10
Graphic 2: 9/10
Graphic 3: 8/10
Graphic 4: 5/10
Graphic 5: 7/10
Graphic 6: 10/10
Graphic 7: 8/10

Two Notes: Car..don't be an over achiever this ain't school hun you don't get extra credit points.
Rai, enjoy my voting scores

Good job everybody. Here's what the scores look like:

Graphic		Participant	Votes	Housepoints
2		Raistlin The Wizard	84	722+150 = 872
6		amberg93	83	714+100 = 814
7		violetriddle	71	568-30+50 = 588
5		amortenia773	58	514
3		Samantha Granger	52	466
1		Hermione.Granger	48	434
4		FaerieOfDoom	42	386

All participants that voted were awarded 50 points. Those who did not vote but submitted a graphic were penalized 30 points.

Scores were multiplied by 8.

The following housepoints are awarded for voting:
Traci=Ronlover102 - 50
Caroru - 50
Sashi - 50
MarieC - 50