Suggestions for Debates

If you have any suggestions for debates we can do in the future, please post your ideas here.

If your suggestion is used, you'll receive ten housepoints.

Percy--Good or Evil? --did u guys do tht one yt?

Amy's Edit: Debate Idea has been used, 10 points awarded

OoOoO....how about one for Harry being either the Heir to Gryffindor??

Ron: Will he betray Harry?

Draco: Is he innocent or not?

Ginny: will she be important in Book 7?

Lily and James vs. Alice and Frank

Hmmm...

I've always wanted to read things about what people think of rumours...

One particular one was that Rowling was going to kill off Harry in the last book...

So: Will Harry Die At The End?

Here's my idea: are all slytherins evil? or is it possible that there could be some genuinely good people in slytherin?

don't know if its already been done but- will dumbledore be back in book7? i.e. did he really die?

(maybe he'll be reincarnated as a purple hippo!)

What about:

Should hogwarts stay open or not?

we already did the one will harry die

But I want to know is will Ron Hermione pairing last

Heres something I would love to debate.

Who will be the insider at Hogwarts who has been working for Voldemort all along feeding him information. I have an idea on who this may be but it would be fun to see if others think it is someone else. We could throw theories out back and forth to get others views. Who knows, by the end of the debate, we might think everyone is guilty of this.


Then we could do the opposite. Who has appeared to be working for Voldemort all along, who is really trying to help the Order and the Ministry. Not Snape, but possibly someone else.

What about a debate on Snape? Is he really and betray Dumbledore or was planned given the circumstances?

Today, I had a "debate" aka arguement with my friend about this. Is Harry Potter (like the series) better than the Lord of the Rings? 'cause I know tehre's a lot of controversy on it...

can they be non-HP discussions? If yes, what about social ladder/ class? It's a subject that came up in the GHCR two days ago or so and it's pretty interesting...

Why are some pure-blood families hate tainting their blood -biased (like the malfoys) Why are some people not like that?

Fred - Is he Really Dead?

I know he is but it would be really hard to debate that he's still alive. It could be interesting...XD

We could do one rather Voldemort really died this time or in the end, he ran off while everyone celebrated.

hmmmm.... how about :
House Elves - Slaves, or Servants? (Your take on the house elves, which you think It could be counted as)
Harry Potter Seven - Split into two movies or not? (I know that i will be, but do you feel it is necessary, or do you think they could squeze it all into one?)

What about;

SAnta Claus : Myth or Moms?

I remembered an article against JK Rowling, it stated there that Rowling was into no good. That she is spreading evil with Harry Potter as an occult. I think it is a good topic, cause lots of sides can be raised. For example, everyone of us here in HE would probably say no she's not, but there are speculations that magic IS evil as it do not goes along with the fact that it is only God who can do anything. Then, as you read this you might already thought of defenses while others may agree.

Harry Potter: an occult for evil?

My friend and I were talking about this the other day and I thought it might make for a good debate topic...

Is it right for Dementors to guard Azkaban?

I just had a really good idea and now I can't remember it! So annoying, I'll post it when I do remember!