The Horcruxes

Admin

Deputy Head

Subject: The Horcruxes Sat Jul 21 2007, 13:54

No surprises really on the identity of the Horcruxes.

The locket, the cup, Ravenclaw's tiara, the snake and Harry.

I was a little surprised that Voldemort made seven horcruxes AND the piece still inside himself, but then he hadn't meant to make Harry one.

The search and destruction of them was very realistically done, it wasn't too easy and it wasn't too hard, which I liked.

Subject: Re: The Horcruxes Sat Jul 21 2007, 14:10

I didn't really think that it would be the tira but it makes sense j.k mentioned it in passing lol!

Subject: Re: The Horcruxes Sat Jul 21 2007, 19:33

Hm, Harry's a Horcrux.

SCORE.

Other than that, I liked how the Horcrux thing went. I thought some parts were a little tooo convenient, such as Crabbe's curse destroying the diadem and Ron and Hermione getting basilisk fangs out of the CoS. When one of the characters said that the two had gone and said something about going to the bathroom, I was surprised Harry was confused. The Chamber of Secrets was the first thing I thought of The Horcruxes 436937

Subject: Re: The Horcruxes Sat Jul 21 2007, 20:29

snake & locket were predictable ones..

but the location of the locket was unusual...

my favorite method of getting a Horcrux was the hufflepuff cup...the flying away on a dragon & hermione being lestrange was ...well unusual

but i don't know why ron actually remembered how to hiss open..& get in the chamber... that part is plain weird..
maybe jk ran out of ideas on how to destroy Horcrux...

Subject: Re: The Horcruxes Sun Jul 22 2007, 04:09

lol possibly, though he has heard Harry speaking parseltongue many times before, so I assume that he simply copied what he could remember.

Yes, no real surprises with what items were the Horcruxes, but I was shocked to find out that harry was on, even though its been debated a lot, its something i didn't think would happen. As soon as this came into light, I cried out that harrys going to die and was really upset, but how it all turned out was simply perfect!

Subject: Re: The Horcruxes Sun Jul 22 2007, 12:33

I've thought Harry was a horcrux for quite some time, although in varying degrees in how firmly I believed it. So, I wasn't too surprised to find out that he was one...I was just worried he wasn't going to survive! But when he did, I felt as though I was able to breathe again-holding your breath for a chapter and five pages gets a little uncomfortable.

I thought it was interesting how the locket showed Ron's worst fears, such as the thing with Harry and Hermione. I wonder if the cup would've done that? And if it did, what did it show Hermione? At least she had Ron with her ^_^

I was a little weirded out about the cup getting destroyed. It was kind of like "...allright then..."

I cheered when Neville killed Nagini :D Good for him!!

Subject: Re: The Horcruxes Mon Jul 23 2007, 09:28

I was kinda surprised how Dumbledore was right on the money about Nagina.. I really thought he was going to be a little off on that one.. but he wasnt :D other than that.. the horcruxes.. seemed well I have one more problem I guess..

WHY did he make his diary a horcrux... I just think that was a little moronic.. but whatever..

Subject: Re: The Horcruxes Thu Aug 19 2010, 00:18

Well I thought Harry was a Horcrux but I didn't want to believe it. I was like no! Harry cannot have a piece of Voldie in him! XD