| The ULTIMATE Poll | |
|
+27Snape_Luffer veritaserumgrl773 skuldandy wizardGIRL25 LOONYkim Gryffindorgal4hp Im_Hermione Samantha Granger hppamela Belldandy pickles weasleybrother08 stephy violetriddle ag167 Alice Cullen Isabella Twilight kathrineee_anne polly Caroru Rigby Dumbledore twilightfairy SlytherinPride7 Elfie Dumbledore Amy amberg93 littleprincess_01 31 posters |
Edward or Jake? | Edward Cullen | | 53% | [ 41 ] | Jacob Black | | 35% | [ 27 ] | Undecided | | 12% | [ 9 ] |
| Total Votes : 77 | | |
|
Author | Message |
---|
littleprincess_01 5th Year
Regist. date : 2006-03-09 Number of posts : 5877 Age : 31 Location : With Milo....Somewhere. =] Real First Name : Aliza Warning : House : Gryffindor Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 22 2008, 13:28 | |
| ...Edward or Jake?
The one that left her, or the one that kept her sane?
The cold one, or the one thats warm and fuzzy?
The one thats too perfect, or the one thats perfect in his imperfections?
xD
...As you can probably tell, I love Jake. I'm still rooting for him! | |
|
| |
amberg93 Deputy Head : Gryffindor HoH : Arithmancy & Arts & Muggle Studies Professor : 5th Year
Country : Regist. date : 2006-03-11 Number of posts : 16910 Age : 31 Location : Canada :P Real First Name : Amber/Amby :D Warning : House : Gryffindor! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 22 2008, 13:32 | |
| *high fives Aliza* Team Jake all the way :D | |
|
| |
Amy Retired Deputy Head : 5th year
Country : Regist. date : 2006-02-22 Number of posts : 11746 Age : 37 Location : England Real First Name : Amy Warning : House : Gryffindor Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 22 2008, 13:36 | |
| I put undecided.
I'm one of the Twilighters who loves Jacob, but still wants Bella with Edward. So...yeah, I'm not in the hating Jake camp but I'm not *quite* a Jacob/Bella shipper. | |
|
| |
Elfie Dumbledore Retired Headmistress : Mick, Snape, The Doctor and Edward Cullen - the men in my life!!
Country : Regist. date : 2006-02-21 Number of posts : 15397 Location : In the land where purple snapes walk Real First Name : Sharon Warning : House : I didn't retire...I surrendered! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 22 2008, 13:46 | |
| Team Edward all the way!!!
Jacob is so childish, self centered, idiotic, stupid....I could go on lol | |
|
| |
SlytherinPride7 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-10-06 Number of posts : 2847 Location : Eating myself, because yes banana's taste GOOD xD Real First Name : Kaylee Warning : House : Slytherin - The Banana In The Muffin :) Crest : Wand : Yew & Dragon Heartstring Award Bar :
| |
| |
amberg93 Deputy Head : Gryffindor HoH : Arithmancy & Arts & Muggle Studies Professor : 5th Year
Country : Regist. date : 2006-03-11 Number of posts : 16910 Age : 31 Location : Canada :P Real First Name : Amber/Amby :D Warning : House : Gryffindor! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 22 2008, 14:17 | |
| Psh Jacob is the best character in the whole series, no one likes him though cause he's not a Gary Stu like Edward He's more like an actual person, Edward is just this perfect unrealistic person thing. | |
|
| |
littleprincess_01 5th Year
Regist. date : 2006-03-09 Number of posts : 5877 Age : 31 Location : With Milo....Somewhere. =] Real First Name : Aliza Warning : House : Gryffindor Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 22 2008, 14:26 | |
| ...Exactly! Or as i said: "The one thats too perfect, or the one thats perfect in his imperfections?" ...Beautifully phrased, even if I do say so myself. xD I love Jake with all my heart! ...ish. Oh and, *high-fives Amber back* | |
|
| |
twilightfairy 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2008-03-04 Number of posts : 924 Age : 35 Location : USA Real First Name : Lily Warning : House : Gryffindor Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 22 2008, 14:28 | |
| Team Edward! I like her better with him | |
|
| |
SlytherinPride7 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-10-06 Number of posts : 2847 Location : Eating myself, because yes banana's taste GOOD xD Real First Name : Kaylee Warning : House : Slytherin - The Banana In The Muffin :) Crest : Wand : Yew & Dragon Heartstring Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 22 2008, 14:34 | |
| | |
|
| |
amberg93 Deputy Head : Gryffindor HoH : Arithmancy & Arts & Muggle Studies Professor : 5th Year
Country : Regist. date : 2006-03-11 Number of posts : 16910 Age : 31 Location : Canada :P Real First Name : Amber/Amby :D Warning : House : Gryffindor! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 22 2008, 15:02 | |
| no, no no! Jake doesn't swing that way xD
And Bella isn't that much of a Mary Sue really, Ginny is much more a Mary Sue! No one ever believes me though! | |
|
| |
Rigby Dumbledore 3rd Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-01-30 Number of posts : 4801 Location : Rêveur Real First Name : Kate or Katie Warning : House : Ravenclaw Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 22 2008, 17:32 | |
| Jacob is childish, manipulative, and selfish. A lot of people attack Edward's character saying that he is too controling of Bella, but it is Jacob that forced himself physically on Bella on one occassion, and then manipulated her into kissing him on another. So, I agree, he is far from a Gary Stu! I think its a shame that Bella and Jacob couldn't just have had a geniune friendship, but then again romantic triangles are far more intriguing.
Edward's my boy- I don't care if he is a Gary Stu. Vampires are supposed to be perfect, enticing creatures, hence their allure. Beauty and sin wrapped into one yummy package. XD
Each of the books has kind of had a theme- Romeo and Juliet, Wuthering Heights. But I liked it best when Bella likened Jacob to Paris, and we all know Paris falls... Now I don't want Jacob dead, as previously stated I would like him to imprint on Angela, but who knows... | |
|
| |
amberg93 Deputy Head : Gryffindor HoH : Arithmancy & Arts & Muggle Studies Professor : 5th Year
Country : Regist. date : 2006-03-11 Number of posts : 16910 Age : 31 Location : Canada :P Real First Name : Amber/Amby :D Warning : House : Gryffindor! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Apr 23 2008, 04:23 | |
| I personally think that everyone is just upset with Jacob because Bella admitted that she was in love with him too, not that she loved him like a brother or something, but that she was also in love with him. Which is something that most people for some reason see as a threat for Edward and Bella. No one can actually appreciate Jacob's actual character, he is by far the best character in the book because he is the one that stirs things up. He's the one who isn't going to give up no matter how greatly the odds are stacked against him! He's the funniest character in the books too!
All everyone ever says though is that he's childish, manipulative, and selfish. But he's human, all of us act that way at times. I'm sorry but if you were madly in love with someone who wasn't in love with you, but in love with someone who planned to kill them (even if they wanted it) would you not want to give everything to keep them with you? To try and win them over, to try and save them? He tried other ways, but he got desperate. He wants what's absolutely best for Bella. Everyone knows that Jacob is the best choice for her, including Edward.
Last edited by amberg93 on Wed Apr 23 2008, 04:57; edited 1 time in total | |
|
| |
Amy Retired Deputy Head : 5th year
Country : Regist. date : 2006-02-22 Number of posts : 11746 Age : 37 Location : England Real First Name : Amy Warning : House : Gryffindor Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Apr 23 2008, 04:55 | |
| Well said, Amber :D | |
|
| |
Caroru HE Owl
Country : Regist. date : 2006-02-24 Number of posts : 15490 Age : 32 Location : Finland Real First Name : Caro Warning : House : Gryffindor Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Apr 23 2008, 08:38 | |
| EDDIE, EDDIE, EDDIE, EDDIE, EDDIE!!!!!!!!!!! :D
*gets behind Team Edward* | |
|
| |
polly 3rd Year
Country : Regist. date : 2006-03-12 Number of posts : 10718 Age : 32 Location : England Real First Name : Polly Warning : House : Ravenclaw! Crest : Wand : Hawthorn and Phoenix Tail Feather Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Apr 23 2008, 09:37 | |
| | |
|
| |
littleprincess_01 5th Year
Regist. date : 2006-03-09 Number of posts : 5877 Age : 31 Location : With Milo....Somewhere. =] Real First Name : Aliza Warning : House : Gryffindor Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Apr 23 2008, 13:30 | |
| Amber, genius response.
READ IT AND WEEP, GUYS!
xD | |
|
| |
kathrineee_anne 5th Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-08-11 Number of posts : 4857 Age : 30 Location : Ragin' Cagin' (you know you love us...) Real First Name : Katherine Warning : House : slytherin. Crest : Wand : Willow and Dragon Heartstring Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Thu Apr 24 2008, 18:22 | |
| I think Jake is a bit too young.... and loving him would be so risky! What if he imprints on someone else! | |
|
| |
Isabella Twilight 1st Year
Regist. date : 2008-04-26 Number of posts : 130 Age : 31 Real First Name : just call me bella Warning : House : Gryffindor Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Sun Apr 27 2008, 14:04 | |
| Edward, though I feel sorry for Jake | |
|
| |
Alice Cullen 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2008-01-12 Number of posts : 1518 Age : 30 Warning : House : Ravenclaw Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Apr 29 2008, 18:26 | |
| ATM I'm on team JACOB but seen as I switch alot between Team Edward, Team Jabob and Team Switzerland I put undecided. I would hate to have to choose between them and Jacob IS childish compared to Edward but thats because Edward is over a hundred years old so OFFCOURSE he will seem more mature compared to Jacob. xD | |
|
| |
Amy Retired Deputy Head : 5th year
Country : Regist. date : 2006-02-22 Number of posts : 11746 Age : 37 Location : England Real First Name : Amy Warning : House : Gryffindor Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Apr 30 2008, 12:06 | |
| All right. I realised today whilst reading New Moon (yes, again :D) that when it comes to this question I'm changeable and influenced by whichever of the books I'm currently reading.
So, when I read Twilight, I'm all for Edward/Bella *gets out E/B flag*
But then when I was reading New Moon today I was really rooting for Jacob/Bella, despite knowing how it ended.
Then when reading Eclipse at times I want E/B and at times J/B. *sigh* So who knows when it comes to Breaking Dawn?
*points to sig* At the moment I'm leaning more towards E/B, but poor Jake *pats him* | |
|
| |
ag167 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-08-04 Number of posts : 7642 Age : 29 Location : England Real First Name : Amy (AG) Warning : House : Slytherin Crest : Wand : Holly and Phoenix Tail Feather Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed May 14 2008, 08:15 | |
| I've just started reading the series, and on book 1, i think i like Edwards better. I like his mannerisms, the way he talks.
TEAM EDWARD
AG
| |
|
| |
violetriddle 5th Year
Country : Regist. date : 2008-02-14 Number of posts : 35370 Age : 31 Location : Alabama Real First Name : Lesley Warning : House : The Wonderful House of Salazar Slytherin Crest : Wand : Walnut & Dragon Heartstring Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed May 14 2008, 08:21 | |
| Sorry yall. But I think EDWARD is for her. But along with Duckie...I was begging for Jake and Bella to kiss or something. But then Edward came back....I told Jake to get lost. Edward is over 100 years old and yes more mature, but what would happen if Bella said something and Jake couldnt control his anger that time.....Edward can control himself *i think* So Edward is better for her because she loves him....but Jake is her friend....and should remain that | |
|
| |
amberg93 Deputy Head : Gryffindor HoH : Arithmancy & Arts & Muggle Studies Professor : 5th Year
Country : Regist. date : 2006-03-11 Number of posts : 16910 Age : 31 Location : Canada :P Real First Name : Amber/Amby :D Warning : House : Gryffindor! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed May 28 2008, 04:30 | |
| See the thing that gets me so badly with Edward is that... he left her. I don't care what the reasoning was, he left her. And knowing all that she felt about him, he did it anyway. Everyone always talks about how mature Edward is and such but honestly how could you take someone back once they caused you that much pain? It just doesn't make sense to me. | |
|
| |
stephy Head Girl : 5th Year : Death Eater
Country : Regist. date : 2006-06-03 Number of posts : 30328 Age : 34 Location : At the Cullen's house stealing Jasper Real First Name : Stephanie, Polly calls me Stephums, Kim calls me Steffie and among others Im either mommy or granny Warning : House : ravenclaw Crest : Wand : Walnut & Phoenix Tail Feather Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Jul 09 2008, 21:18 | |
| | |
|
| |
weasleybrother08 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2008-03-19 Number of posts : 2939 Age : 36 Real First Name : Anthony Warning : House : Gryffindor Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Aug 13 2008, 20:47 | |
| Team Edward, I like his character better, plus vampires rock | |
|
| |
pickles 2nd Year
Country : Regist. date : 2008-02-21 Number of posts : 6322 Age : 30 Location : N. Ireland Real First Name : Matthew Warning : House : Hufflepuff! I'm like the only guy! Crest : Wand : Oak & Heart Dragonstring Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Thu Aug 14 2008, 04:23 | |
| TEAM EDWARD! Right i actually didn't know there was thisd many people in team jake??? Well done you guys for being different. I'm on team Edward because well, he's the good looking one with all them manners. Bella needed someone to give her a life she needed and Edward has always been the one for her. Yes, I'll say that I undecided when Edward left in New moon but I was never a team Jake because he's just so, ermm... I don't know the word... Ermm careful. I'm very like Bella I would be with the most dangerous of the two. I think she loved the danger of being with Edward more than she liked him. And I'm the same. So Team Edward! | |
|
| |
Belldandy 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2008-04-12 Number of posts : 221 Age : 31 Location : somewhere Real First Name : Alice Warning : House : R.A.V.E.N.C.L.A.W.!!!!!!!!!! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Fri Aug 15 2008, 17:20 | |
| TEAM EDWARD!!! I really don't like Jake. Especially after what he did in Breaking Dawn! | |
|
| |
hppamela 5th Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-11-04 Number of posts : 5190 Age : 41 Location : Valparaiso, In Real First Name : Pamela Warning : House : Gryffie Lion--Hear my roar! Crest : Wand : Holly and Phoenix Tail Feather Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Mon Sep 01 2008, 13:33 | |
| Well, I was Team Jacob. I love Edward, don't get me wrong. Their relationship was unhealthy, though. I've needed someone that badly. I have responded to the loss that badly. It's not a healthy way to love. | |
|
| |
Samantha Granger 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-08-20 Number of posts : 10257 Location : Exploring the galaxy in my Leviathan Real First Name : Jayme Warning : House : Gryffindor!!!! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Sep 02 2008, 18:24 | |
| I love Jake, but she totally belongs with Edward | |
|
| |
Im_Hermione 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-08-16 Number of posts : 4793 Age : 31 Location : Under your bed. Real First Name : Erika//Eka Warning : House : Gryffindor Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Mon Mar 16 2009, 21:31 | |
| TEAM EDWARD!!!
(they are both very sexy but there is something about edward i like better ^^ ((maybe part that hes a vampire, sparkles in the sun and plays baseball in the rain? XD)) ) | |
|
| |
Gryffindorgal4hp 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2008-02-14 Number of posts : 7979 Age : 31 Real First Name : Lucy Warning : House : Gryffindor (Huffenclaw at heart) Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Apr 08 2009, 16:20 | |
| TEAM EDWARD!
Even though I'm not really that into Twilight
LucyXX | |
|
| |
LOONYkim 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-10-08 Number of posts : 8321 Age : 30 Location : burning upp Real First Name : some call me Ropie. thats good enough for you to know. xD Warning : House : witty and clever forever and ever!!! go ravenclaw!!! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Apr 08 2009, 17:46 | |
| i voted team Jacob. I love Jacob, he is waay hotter than Edward. I honestly think there is no word to describe how good looking he is. XD
But I don't only like him because he is hot! I think he is very sweet. I think that Bella and Jake mesh better together than Edward and Bella. I think that though their relationship gets rocky (B/J) they always apologize to each other. Jake is immature, but seriously, would you have a chance of maturity against a 100+ year old person? Edward is waaaay mature, but he is immature at times too, because he still has teen hormones, even though they are vampire-ish. I love Edward, don't get me wrong. He is great looking, the perfect BF. But I think that humans can't comprehend perfect-ness too well, because we don't come across it, ever. I think she likes the comfort of Jake, and how she can be free with him, a lighter spirit- young, freeminded, no worries, or at least it feels like it. She says so herself that's how she feels.
So...I love dudes!! Edward is smooth, perfect, gentle. He is very protective, but what boyfriend isnt? He is everything Bella needs. The perfect romance, the one I am deperately jelous for. But I think that Jake is more of a reality. He is human, he is a cutie! He is strong, and warm, just what girls love. I could endlessly describe both, but I would rather have a warm werewolf to cuddle up to rather than a chilly vampire. | |
|
| |
wizardGIRL25 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2008-01-01 Number of posts : 3547 Age : 30 Location : Waiting at the Crossroads Real First Name : Andreya Warning : House : Slytherin Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Apr 08 2009, 17:49 | |
| Team Jacon...even though I am sooooo not obsessed with twilight...Jacob... | |
|
| |
skuldandy 3rd Year
Country : Regist. date : 2006-02-26 Number of posts : 3442 Age : 32 Location : Portugal Real First Name : skully! Warning : House : Gryffies! <3 Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Thu Jun 18 2009, 07:00 | |
| Edward&Bella
Jacob&Me
This is MY vote :D | |
|
| |
veritaserumgrl773 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2009-07-22 Number of posts : 1332 Age : 29 Location : Music... bootcamp... going...crazy. Can't. finish. *twitch* Real First Name : Kat Warning : House : Ravenclaw Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Thu Jul 23 2009, 09:46 | |
| Team Edward all the way! xD
Jacob is too....bleck, he just manipulates Bella in my opinion though I am appreciative of him making Bella snap out of her depression in New Moon (:
xxKat | |
|
| |
Im_Hermione 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-08-16 Number of posts : 4793 Age : 31 Location : Under your bed. Real First Name : Erika//Eka Warning : House : Gryffindor Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| |
| |
Snape_Luffer 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-09-24 Number of posts : 6331 Age : 31 Location : Orlando Real First Name : Rosalie call me Rose Warning : House : Huffley Puff!!! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Thu Aug 13 2009, 20:25 | |
| So totally neather, man. Seth Clearwater is the one for me <3 | |
|
| |
Clafin 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2009-07-17 Number of posts : 10947 Age : 31 Location : In the magical land of glitter! Real First Name : Caitee Warning : House : Gryffindor Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Thu Aug 13 2009, 20:32 | |
| | |
|
| |
geordie_lass43 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-07-18 Number of posts : 360 Age : 31 Location : Up On The Clouds :) Real First Name : Kaytie Warning : House : Hufflepuff Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Wed Dec 30 2009, 02:51 | |
| Team Jacob. I do like Edward he is better for Bella, but Jacob soo brings out Bella's wild side :D | |
|
| |
dracofan89 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2008-02-09 Number of posts : 324 Age : 35 Location : USA Real First Name : Margie Warning : House : Hufflepuff Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Jan 05 2010, 22:25 | |
| Team Jacob definitly | |
|
| |
Jamoki 1st Year
Country : Regist. date : 2007-12-09 Number of posts : 2374 Age : 30 Location : Slytherin Common Room Real First Name : Clinton Warning : House : Slytherin! Crest : Wand : Exam not taken Award Bar :
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll Tue Jul 20 2010, 05:45 | |
| Sorry Edward and Jake, but for me, its Team Emmett | |
|
| |
Sponsored content
| Subject: Re: The ULTIMATE Poll | |
| |
|
| |
| The ULTIMATE Poll | |
|