JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Rock V Classical

Admin

Deputy Head

Subject: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Rock V Classical Thu Jul 31 2008, 13:36

JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Rock V Classical
Judges: Elfie Dumbledore, Duck the duck and Raistlin the Wizard

Those who participated in this:

Belldandy
Ellemanae
violetriddle
kathrineee_anne
polly
Elana
skyla0305
Severus Snape

To judges:

Each participant needs to be marked out of 100 for their entry. How you mark them is up to you. Look at creativity, individuality and style as well as relevance, clothing and hair choice and background etc.

Look at models clothes, hair, pose and background
Also
look at the two shots together, making sure that not only do they fit
well with each of the opposites, but also sit well together

For
each person put their mark out of 50 for this category and write a few
things on what you thought was good and what could be improved (ie:
what they lost marks for)

Scores will go up when each judge has marked each participant. Scores will be an average of all three scores.

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Rock V Classical Thu Jul 31 2008, 14:06

Elfies Marks

Belldandy 78
On first look you can clearly see what both shots are portraying. Poses together seem a little stiff (ie: poses not working well together as in one shot) though you have done an all round good job. Your rock shot is great and completely oposes the classical shot. Not overly keen on the rock choice of clothing though it works well.

Ellemanae 90
The first thing that came out for me is how well both shots have been merged together to create that one whole shot. Focusing upon one colour with clothing and style works really well and both shots work very well together and seperate. Facial expressions did not change though which is a shame.

violetriddle 51
I cant really see these two going well together as style choices havent been thought over too much with regards to merging both shots. As seperate shots I have mixed views. You have performed much better in the rock shot, perhaps closer to your own style? There is certainly a more comfortable feeling with that shot. Your classical style is too mary poppins in the park for my liking Im afraid.

kathrineee_anne 59
These styles work well together. Perhaps would have been better on oposite sides to one another so that classical was leaning towards rock. It does not immediately how these oposites though you have taken a slightly different look on this. With rock, there just is not enough thought to show what I was wanting to see.

polly 63
Firstly, the two shots seem only to stand alone and not together which is what we were also looking for. Seperately, your classical excels well past your rock shot. The hat promotes everything else except rock, and the cat teddy item just doesnt work for me. Classical, though is great.

Elana 70
This is certainly a difference to all of the dark colours I have seen so far. I especially like the classical shot and although the rock shot certainly shows rock, I just can not bring myself to like it. They do sit well together, though, which is great.

skyla0305 95
Modern day princess V modern day rock princess. These shots are great and work really well together. Perhaps choker or some kind of neck jewelry would have been good with your rock shot. Not may negatives at all here, well done.

Severus Snape 85
This is great. Im not sure whether as the only male in the competition you have an advantage or disadvantage, though it seems after that terrible mistake in the last round, you have brought back your running shoes! This could be one shot - it is really positioned well. Styles are great, though something not quite right though I cant put my finger on it. Perhaps the use of props hides the true shots?

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Rock V Classical Thu Aug 07 2008, 16:21

(Dis)Classified Clothes vs Rock and Burn your scores (aka Marking)

Belldandy - 70
Overall a good job I would say though the classical could be better.

Ellemenae - 90
Me likes it! Shiny!

violetriddle - 65
Interpretation is good i just dont really like the classical dress!

k-anne - 65
Too simple...

polly - 70
Im sure you havent been to many rock concerts lately.

Elana - 70
This one put a smile in my face for trying to pull that rock outfit off so cookie points.

skyla0305 - 70
I buy this one.

Severus Snape - 65
Fashion is always so unfair on man.

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Rock V Classical Mon Aug 11 2008, 12:36

Due to our third judge being away on holiday, we have asked a third party to score for the third judge. Please note that they are simply scoring with no comments. These will be averages with mine and rais scores.

There scores are as follows;

Belldandy : 85
Ellemanae : 95
violetriddle : 45
kathrineee_anne : 55
polly : 68
Elana : 70
skyla0305 : 90
Severus Snape : 85

Subject: Re: JUDGES THREAD : Round 5 : Rock V Classical Mon Aug 11 2008, 12:42

You averaged final scores are as follows;

Ellemanae : 90, 90, 95 (92)

skyla0305 : 95, 70, 90 (85)

Severus Snape : 85, 65, 85
(79)

Belldandy : 78, 70, 85 (78)

Elana : 70, 70, 70 (70)

polly : 63, 70, 68 (67)

kathrineee_anne : 59, 65, 55
(60)
violetriddle : 51, 65, 45 (54)

» NTM - ROUND 5 - PART 1 : OPPOSITES : Rock V Classical
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 4 : Air
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 1 - Greed
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 1 - Sloth
» JUDGES THREAD : Round 1 - Wrath