Unanswered Questions

erg so many questions now that i want answering erg elfie lol.

i also want to know ho harrys other godparents are.

EDITED DUE TO DOUBLE POST!

ok, ill try to answer a few of what i think! No throwing large objects if you disagree lol

Will Hogwarts open in the fall? I think it will, and I think we will see Harry attend it only to aid him on his 'quest'
What/where are the remaining Horcruxes? Perhaps we will see one found back at Harry, James and Lily's old house...?
Why did Voldemort give Lily the chance to live? Perhaps he had a little bit of conscience inside of him...? no, probably not!
Who is the person who will do magic at a later-than-normal age?Well this is a question i never even thought of. The only answer I have is perhaps Lilys sister petunia
Is Snape loyal to Voldemort, or to the Order of the Phoenix? I refuse to answer in case Elfie reads this lol
Why did Dumbledore trust Snape? Again, i refuse to answer for fear of large flying objects being thrown in my direction
What is behind the veil? Sirius!!!
What will happen to Draco Malfoy? Harry may take pitty on him and help him. I dont think he will die though
Is Harry's eye color significant? Another question I havent thought of. Is there a reason why it would be?
What will be the final revelation about Lily Potter? Perhaps something to do with why Voldy offered her a chance to live, again i am clueless to the answer.
Is Harry a descendant of Godric Gryffindor? It is possible, after all, James' family is pure blood decendants which could lead back to Godric.
What careers will the survivors of the war pursue? I dont think this will even be covered in the last book
Who is R.A.B.? I'll stick with the popular belief of Sirius' brother Regulus
How does one destroy a Horcrux, anyway? Hasnt this already been covered in the books?
How did Harry's family come into so much gold? Hmmm, I am not sure...
How will Percy / will Percy redeem himself? I wouldnt forgive him!!
To whom has Percy been loyal since he split with the family? Well...the ministry
Will Ron's scars from the brains in the Department of Mysteries have any further significance?I dont think so
Will we see Viktor Krum in Bulgaria, or will he come to Western Europe?If we see him, itll be in England with hermione
Is Nympahdora's Muggle father Ted the newscaster from the first book? What??
Will Dumbledore's portrait play a role?yes, most certainly
What happened to Ollivander and Florean Fortescue? Ollivander was taken by Voldy's followers, I am not sure about florean.
Where's Fawkes? Who owns him now? I think that Fawkes will join Harry at some point, after all, Harry is still loyal to DD, and therefore fawkes will be loyal to harry.
What did James and Lily do for a living? lol not a clue - I am really having to try to think about these answers!
What is / what's in in the "love" room in the Department of Mysteries? I cant even remember that room **goes to read the books again**
What happened to Sirius' two-way mirror? How will it play a role?
Now that is the question. I think it will play a role as it was a significant thing that hasnt been used yet, how and why, though, i am not sure
Will we / how will we see Sirius again? see above possibly
What else does Petunia know about the magical world? One thing is for certain, she knows much more that she is letting on
Who is the series's last Defense Against the Dark Arts professor? I dont think we will get to see it as we will follow Harry who i believe will not attend regular hogwarts
Where is the Death Eater headquarters? Hmmm, again i am not sure
How does Dumbledore's family play into the last book? His family? Perhaps they are linked with harry somehow
What is Aberforth Dumbledore's role in the Order of the Phoenix, and what will it be in the final resolution? These are difficult questions...
Does anyone else know about the Horcruxes besides Harry and his gang?Well voldemort does and of course the trio...
Why hasn't Voldemort just made more Horcruxes since returning to life? Has he? I dont think so as he made horcruxes to match the most powerful number...
What was Snape and Lily's relationship like? perhaps he loved her...well thats what i have heard...
Which Hogwarts teachers are married, and what significance does that have to the overall plot? Why haven't we heard about their marriages before? I dont think it will have any significance...
What story did Snape tell Dumbledore to gain his trust?Thats what i'd like to know...
Jo has said that Ravenclaw will "have its day" - how? Perhaps all three houses will unite (minus slytherin) to aid in the final battle
What did the potion in the cave to do Dumbledore? Wasnt that answered by Dumbledore?
Was Dumbledore going to die anyway, because of the potion? I think he was going to die anyway, through old age perhaps...perhaps he used the philosophers stone...
What was Dumbledore seeing when he drank that potion? Elfie tried to put all the words together and says she has an idea but wont tell me...I am going to try to find out lol
Why did students give Harry all the notes from Dumbledore in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince ? I really need to read it again - i cant remember that part...
What is the story behind Dumbledore's hand injury from Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince? It was when he was destroying a horcrux wasnt it?
Why did the Horcrux ring have the Peverell crest on it? Not sure
Are there any other Unbreakable Vows currently in place? Maybe another involving snape protecting harry
How will Wormtail's life-debt be repaid, if it is? I think it will as DD said, though how? hmm maybe helping save harry though Snape may be the one for that (according to elfie) so i am not sure.



A lot of questions - ill come back with more answers later :D

Who retrieved Voldemort's wand from Godric's Hollow? - Well, if you read the theory Amy posted about McGonagall being the hidden traitor-then it could be her.

What was contained in the other letters Dumbledore and Petunia wrote to each other?-Possibly inner workings of Harry's protection?

Who is the person who loved Snape? His mother? - Most likely his mother-or Elfie :D

Where was Neville when his parents were tortured?-In the crib. I've heard theories that the reason Neville's memories are so bad are because a powerful wizard cast a memory charm on him. Being only a little baby, the magic would've been too much. And if you think that this makes no sense because how would a 1 yr old remember things like this-well, look at Harry! He can remember some details from the night his parents were killed.

Is Neville Longbottom under a memory charm that's wearing off?-I answer that above

Who is "that awful boy" that Petunia overheard Lily talking to?-Snape, maybe. He did have a "crush" on Lily and she didn't overtly hate him. Or even James, Petunia wasn't particularly fond of him either.

Why did Dumbledore have James's invisibility cloak? - Since James believed that Wormtail wouldn't betray him why would he need to stay hidden in a hidden house? Maybe in case he needed to escape-Dumbledore could sneak it to the house? Weak, I know, but an answer.

Was Dumbledore an Animagus? - Probably-he certainly was powerful enough to have been.

Will we discover the identities of the other registered animagi?-Other registered animagi may show up in the final battle, or guarding people.

Will the time turner make a reappearance? - It would complicate things too much, in my opinion. But maybe it would be used as a diversionary tactic-As Harry #1 fights a Death Eater Harry #2 destroys the final horcrux.

Who else was at Godric's Hollow the night of Harry's parents's deaths?-McGonagall-to collect Voldy's wand -Hagrid, Dumbledore...assorted muggles.

Dumbledore says that one person alone could not have retrieved the locket. Who was R.A.B.'s accomplice in doing so? - Go to the interesting discussion Amy and I are having.

What did Dudley see when the Dementors approached?-Maybe being locked in a glass cage or being attacked by some snake while he was eleven?

How/why will we see the Ford Anglia again?-Oh yes, most definitely. That thing running rampant in the Forest wont do. Maybe it'll run over Voldemort.

What will become of Rita Skeeter?-Someone will accidentally smush her while she is in bug mode.

Do the kids become members of the Order of the Phoenix as soon as they are of age, or is there an initiation process that we have yet to see?- Since the Order is very secret, they probably don't have many 17 year old kids coming up to join it. There may be a "trial mission" they have to go in if they want to join, and if they do well (or survive?) they're in.

Will the house-elves ever stand up for themselves / will Hermione's efforts on their welfare be wasted?-I think Dobby will have an army of house-elves.
"Say hello to Dobby's little friends!!!"

Are there other Hogwarts heirs besides Voldemort?-Harry is most likely Gryffindor's. And Hepzibah Smith was Hufflepuff's (I think) Ravenclaw however, remains illusive. (Hermione???? :D)

What will become of Dumbledore's Army? - If Harry and the others aren't let in the Order of the Phoenix, they could probably re-instate the army.

Will Norbert return?-YES! Charlie will make his grand entrance flying in on Norbert and will burn MacNair to a crisp!!

Who leads the Order of the Phoenix without Dumbledore?-Snape's out, McGonagall might not have ever been in it. So, Arthur Weasley, Remus Lupin, Mad-eye Moody....I'm gonna go with Moody

Why was there a gleam in Dumbledore's eye when he learned that Voldemort now has Harry's blood running through his veins?-Since Voldemort now has the blood of a human-could he now be human? There could be something in Harry's blood that now is in Voldemort's blood-a weakness?

Ginny, Neville, Harry and Luna could hear the whispers at the veil at the Department of Mysteries; of them, we know three of them (Harry, Neville and Luna) could see the Thestrals, and therefore have witnessed death. Are these things related? Why were they affected by this when others apparently weren't?-I think that they've all witnessed death, except for Ginny. Maybe Ginny saw someone die in the battle up until the Veil point?

And those are all horrible answers but woot I wrote them down.

for the snape and lily relationship question, im pretty sure snape hated lily cuz she was a ''mudblood'' and all and i really dont thinke he liked her saving his butt all the time when he was being bullied by james ... cuz it musta hurt his ego to owe it to sum1 he dusnt like in the first place, and he definately wasnt gratefull. and lily... i think she felt bad for snape... but im not so sure about her.

these are very interesting. i hope you dont mind, i have made a seperate post for some of the things you have mentioned

Holy Sugar bears Elfie, this is going to take me a month to answer!!!!! LOL

Will Hogwarts open in the fall? Yes, I believe it will. The students are safer there than at their homes.

What/where are the remaining Horcruxes? The locket, the hufflepuff cup, Nagini and Tom Riddle's special service to the school award.

Why did Voldemort give Lily the chance to live? He had no reason to kill her. It was Harry he wanted. But I wonder if Snape asked Voldemort not to kill her.

Who is the person who will do magic at a later-than-normal age?Mrs Figg or Filtch

Is Snape loyal to Voldemort, or to the Order of the Phoenix?To the Order. He is good. He is a hero!

Why did Dumbledore trust Snape?Snape knows something that no one else knows besides himself and Dumbledore. Snape made an unbreakable vow swearing to protect Harry at all costs.

What is behind the veil?Witches and wizards that died by the veil. It is like a netherworld.

What will happen to Draco Malfoy? He will eventually see that Voldemort is nothing but a life destroyer. He will see how the dark side of magic has destroyed his family. He will definitly go over to the Order and help Harry.

Is Harry's eye color significant? It has to be. It is mentioned several times.

What will be the final revelation about Lily Potter? That she died for her son. Her blood enabled Harry to become the wizard that ended the Dark Lord forever.

Is Harry a descendant of Godric Gryffindor? I am not sure on this one. It would make sense if he was, but why was it never mentioned to him before. It is a big thing. You would think someone would have told him. He did pull out the Gryffindor sword out of the hat. How did he do it if he is not a true Gryffindor. I am torn on this one.

What careers will the survivors of the war pursue? Harry will be DADA professor, Ron Auror, Hermione, Healer, Neville Herbology professor.

Who is R.A.B.? I think it is regulas black or a group of three people each making up one initial. If it is Regulas, he couldn't have done it alone.

How does one destroy a Horcrux, anyway? I guess you have to destroy the object completley so no trace of soul could possibly remain there.

How did Harry's family come into so much gold? I think the Potters were rich. Or maybe it is because he is an Heir of Gryffindor.

How will Percy / will Percy redeem himself? It is going to take a lot for him to redeem himself in the eyes of his Father, Ron, Fred and George. He would have to risk his life to save one of them.

To whom has Percy been loyal since he split with the family? The ministry and himself.

Will Ron's scars from the brains in the Department of Mysteries have any further significance? I don't think so. I think if it did we would have seen a glimpse of it in the Half Blood Prince.

Will we see Viktor Krum in Bulgaria, or will he come to Western Europe? I think he will meet up with Harry wherever Harry is. I hope he is going to be there to be on Harry's side, not against him.

Is Nympahdora's Muggle father Ted the newscaster from the first book? Could be, haven't thought of that before.

Will Dumbledore's portrait play a role? - I think that it will. Harry can talk to him and maybe get some ideas on where to look for the horcruxes.

What happened to Ollivander and Florean Fortescue? - Olivander I believe was kiddnapped to make Voldemort a new wand.

Where's Fawkes? Who owns him now? I think Fawkes will go to Harry now.

What did James and Lily do for a living? I think they were probably Aurors or work for the ministry.

What is / what's in in the "love" room in the Department of Mysteries? Probably some pretty potent love potion...I don't know. Maybe it is a record of everyones love life..LOL

What happened to Sirius' two-way mirror? How will it play a role? The mirror will play a role. It was brought into the series for a reason.

Will we / how will we see Sirius again? I think in the veil. He will be able to communicate with Harry there and possibly also with the two way mirror.

What else does Petunia know about the magical world? I think she knows a lot more than what she is telling anyone. Maybe she holds some secret to the undoing of Voldemort.

Who is the series's last Defense Against the Dark Arts professor? I hope Lupin will come back. If not him than I am sure it will be someone we never heard of. If it is Umbridge, I will puke.

Where is the Death Eater headquarters? I am guessing at Voldemort's Fathers house.

How does Dumbledore's family play into the last book? He will be able to communicate somewhat with Harry via the portrait.

What is Aberforth Dumbledore's role in the Order of the Phoenix, and what will it be in the final resolution? This one I have no idea on at all.

Does anyone else know about the Horcruxes besides Harry and his gang? Voldemort and his gang I am sure, but maybe someone in the ministry may know as well.

Why hasn't Voldemort just made more Horcruxes since returning to life? Has he? He can't he hardly has a soul left at all now. If he split it again I think there would be nothing left of him.

What was Snape and Lily's relationship like? I think they were good friends. He probably liked her romantically but I don't think that they dated.

Which Hogwarts teachers are married, and what significance does that have to the overall plot? Why haven't we heard about their marriages before? I don't think any of them are married. I think if they were we would have read about it by now.

What story did Snape tell Dumbledore to gain his trust? I think Snape made an unbreakable vow to protect Harry's life at all costs and that is why Dumbledore trusts him.

Jo has said that Ravenclaw will "have its day" - how? I am thinking that Loony will kick some serious Deatheater butt!! GO LUNA!!

What did the potion in the cave to do Dumbledore? I think it weakened him quite a lot and was killing him.

Was Dumbledore going to die anyway, because of the potion? He was going to die either by the potion or with the unbreakable vow HE did with Narcissa (I think it was Dumbledore in Spinner's end, not Snape)

What was Dumbledore seeing when he drank that potion? - I think it made him wittness something horrible that either happened in his life or something that someone else had wittnessed and Dumbledore saw in the pensieve at one time

Why did students give Harry all the notes from Dumbledore in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince ? I think he didn't want anyone to see him giving Harry the notes himself. He didn't want anyone to know about the lessons they were having.

What is the story behind Dumbledore's hand injury from Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince? He found Marvolo's ring and put it on. Then the ring killed his hand. I think that's pretty much all there is to it.

Why did the Horcrux ring have the Peverell crest on it? It must have had something to do with Marvolo or the Gaunt family.

Are there any other Unbreakable Vows currently in place? Yep. I think Snape and Dumbledore made one about protecting Harry.

How will Wormtail's life-debt be repaid, if it is? I think he will end up helping Harry. Voldemort treats Wormtail like crap and eventually he will get sick of it. He will remember how much he liked James and he will help Harry.

Who retrieved Voldemort's wand from Godric's Hollow? I bet it is someone that we all think is good that is really not. No one on his side got it, otherwise they would have known Voldemort was not dead. His Deatheaters all believed him to be dead. So it HAS to be someone from the other side!

What was contained in the other letters Dumbledore and Petunia wrote to each other? There was something in them. Maybe it was instructions on something she needed to do if Dumbledore died before Harry turned 17, but I am sure we will find out in book 7.

Who is the person who loved Snape? His mother? I think it was either Lily or someone that he loved that we don't know about yet..Narcissa...Bellatrix???

Where was Neville when his parents were tortured? I think he was probably with his Grandmother.

Is Neville Longbottom under a memory charm that's wearing off? Never thought of this. It is possible.

Who is "that awful boy" that Petunia overheard Lily talking to? either Sirius or Snape I am guessing.

Why did Dumbledore have James's invisibility cloak? Possibly he borrowed it from James for something? This question has always interested me.

Was Dumbledore an Animagus? I am certain he qwas. He is an excellent wizard, surely he would have known how to become an animagus...

Will we discover the identities of the other registered animagi? Yes, and I think Nagini is one...I have an idea who it is too!

Will the time turner make a reappearance? sadly no, They were all destroyed.

Who else was at Godric's Hollow the night of Harry's parents's deaths? Someone was there....I think it will be the traitor in the series.

Dumbledore says that one person alone could not have retrieved the locket. Who was R.A.B.'s accomplice in doing so? If it was Regulas than I think Kreature went along with him.

What did Dudley see when the Dementors approached? I think it mentioned when he was really sick.

How/why will we see the Ford Anglia again? I don't think so. I thnk it already served it's purpose.

What will become of Rita Skeeter? Hopefulyy she will get sent to Azkaban...can't stand her.

Do the kids become members of the Order of the Phoenix as soon as they are of age, or is there an initiation process that we have yet to see? I think they would have to prove their loyalties in some way to the order before they are allowed in.

Will the house-elves ever stand up for themselves / will Hermione's efforts on their welfare be wasted? I think they are all happy where they are and will stay where they are needed.

Are there other Hogwarts heirs besides Voldemort? Possibly Harry, not sure about the others.

What will become of Dumbledore's Army? I think Luna and Neville will run the order while Harry is gone and recruit new members and strengthen old ones to fight in the final battle.

Will Norbert return? I really don't think he will.

Who leads the Order of the Phoenix without Dumbledore? Lupin and Tonks.

Why was there a gleam in Dumbledore's eye when he learned that Voldemort now has Harry's blood running through his veins? Because he knows Voldemort will be weaker not that he has the power of love running through his veins.

Ginny, Neville, Harry and Luna could hear the whispers at the veil at the Department of Mysteries; of them, we know three of them (Harry, Neville and Luna) could see the Thestrals, and therefore have witnessed death. Are these things related? Why were they affected by this when others apparently weren't? I think they must be realted, otherwise they all would have heard the voices. I am not sure what it all means, but it has to be signifigant!


WOOOHOOOOO I'm done!! It took me an hour!! WOW...Good way to get us thinking Elfie!! <3

Will Hogwarts open in the fall? Yes, but Harry, Ron, and Hermione won't be students

What/where are the remaining Horcruxes? Godric's Hollow, the orphange

Why did Voldemort give Lily the chance to live? Snape was involved.

Who is the person who will do magic at a later-than-normal age? Dear old Figgy

Is Snape loyal to Voldemort, or to the Order of the Phoenix? Voldemort

Why did Dumbledore trust Snape? An Unbreakable Vow

What is behind the veil? A doorway to the dead

What will happen to Draco Malfoy? He will redeem himself

Is Harry's eye color significant? No

What will be the final revelation about Lily Potter? I don't know

Is Harry a descendant of Godric Gryffindor? Not technically, put emotionally

What careers will survivors of the war pursue? Aurors, teachers

Who is R.A.B.? Regulus

How does one destroy a Horcrux, anyway? it is diffrent every time

Howdid Harry's family come into so much gold? inheritance

How will Percy / will Percy redeem himself? sacrificng himself

To whom has Percy been loyal since he split with the family? Penelope Clearwater, his old girlfriend and of coarse, the ministry

Will Ron's scars from the brains in the Department of Mysteries have any further significance? No

Will we see Viktor Krum in Bulgaria, or will he come to Western Europe? He'll come to help Harry

Is Nympahdora's Muggle father Ted the newscaster from the first book? Yes

Will Dumbledore's portrait play a role? Yea

What happened to Ollivander and Florean Fortescue? There with Voldemort-- Ollivander for his wands and Fortescue-- for his knowledge of History of magic

Where's Fawkes? Who owns him now? Aberforth

What did James and Lily do for a living? Aurors in training

What happened to Sirius' two-way mirror? How will it play a role? Harry and the trio or Ginny

Will we / how will we see Sirius again? portrait

What else does Petunia know about the magical world? COuld know crucial information about Voldemort and the last war

Who is the series's last Defense Against the Dark Arts professor? doesn't mention

Where is the Death Eater headquarters? Riddle House

How does Dumbledore's family play into the last book? We meet Aberforth

What is Aberforth Dumbledore's role in the Order of the Phoenix, and what will it be in the final resolution? spy, he'll have informatio about Dumbledore for Harry thats crucial

Does anyone else know about the Horcruxes besides Harry and his gang?Aberforth?

Why hasn't Voldemort just made more Horcruxes since returning to life? Has he? no, 7 is most powerful number

What was Snape and Lily's relationship like? Love-Hate

Which Hogwarts teachers are married, and what significance does that have to the overall plot? Why haven't we heard about their marriages before? no significence

What story did Snape tell Dumbledore to gain his trust? how he loved Lily

Jo has said that Ravenclaw will "have its day" - how? they will find a horcrux

What did the potion in the cave to do Dumbledore? like a dementor/boggart

Was Dumbledore going to die anyway, because of the potion? Eventually, in a few hours, days

What was Dumbledore seeing when he drank that potion? Worst fears

What is the story behind Dumbledore's hand injury from Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince? DUmbledore thought he had destroyed the horcrux so he put it on and it withered his hand much like the potion did to his brain

Why did the Horcrux ring have the Peverell crest on it? Cousins

Are there any other Unbreakable Vows currently in place? possibly

How will Wormtail's life-debt be repaid, if it is? He will sacrifce himself for Harry

Who retrieved Voldemort's wand from Godric's Hollow? Snape

What was contained in the other letters Dumbledore and Petunia wrote to each other? Instructions for Harry, news on the wizarding world

Who is the person who loved Snape? His mother? Lily

Where was Neville when his parents were tortured? With them much like Harry

Is Neville Longbottom under a memory charm that's wearing off? No

Who is "that awful boy" that Petunia overheard Lily talking to? James

Why did Dumbledore have James's invisibility cloak? for a order mission

Was Dumbledore an Animagus? maybe, I doubt it

Will we discover the identities of the other registered animagi? no

Will the time turner make a reappearance? no

Who else was at Godric's Hollow the night of Harry's parents's deaths? SNape

Dumbledore says that one person alone could not have retrieved the locket. Who was R.A.B.'s accomplice in doing so? Kreacher

How/why will we see the Ford Anglia again? NO

What will become of Rita Skeeter? nothing

Do the kids become members of the Order of the Phoenix as soon as they are of age, or is there an initiation process that we have yet to see? Harry will probably, but there has to be some sort of initiation

Will the house-elves ever stand up for themselves / will Hermione's efforts on their welfare be wasted? wasted

Are there other Hogwarts heirs besides Voldemort? Aberforth

What will become of Dumbledore's Army? nothing

Will Norbert return? no

Who leads the Order of the Phoenix without Dumbledore? Lupin?

Why was there a gleam in Dumbledore's eye when he learned that Voldemort now has Harry's blood running through his veins? weakness