| | Narnia vs. Middle-earth |  |
|
+22Blue Rabbit Babe SlytherinPride7 hppamela ginnyunited Dancingsunset drkangelcat Rockheart stephy kikso Puppet_Master Elana Samantha Granger WytchKitty polly magicguy93 Bella Muerte Ellemanae cookiemonster dragonweaver Katana-RN Ramiela BookMasterJMV 26 posters |
| Which "world" do you prefer? Consider all parts of it too: books, movies, etc. | | C.S. Lewis and Narnia | | 27% | [ 9 ] | | J.R.R. Tolkien and Middle-earth | | 52% | [ 17 ] | | I love them both equally! I cannot decide! | | 21% | [ 7 ] |
| | Total Votes : 33 | | | |
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
BookMasterJMV
1st Year
Country : 
Regist. date : 2007-08-09
Number of posts : 2691
Age : 39
Location : Henderson, Nevada, USA
Real First Name : Justin
Warning :
House : Ravenclaw - Home of the Eagles
Crest : 
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
 |  Subject: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Tue Aug 14 2007, 00:43 | |
| This topic is brought to you by a discussion some HEers had this evening in the CBox. For more chats like these, join us when the night is waning and the eyes are straining.
So this is the question: do you prefer the world of Narnia as created by C.S. Lewis or the world of Middle-earth as created by J.R.R. Tolkien? Remember, take all things into consideration: books, movies, games, etc.
Does your heart beat for Prince Caspian or Prince Legolas?
Who's better with the bow? Arwen or Susan?
Only time will tell.
(Oh yes, and my vote goes for LotR!) | |
|
| | |
Ramiela
1st Year
Regist. date : 2007-08-06
Number of posts : 488
Location : Montana
Real First Name : Ramiela or Rama
Warning :
House : Hufflepuff
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Tue Aug 14 2007, 09:20 | |
| I have to go with Middle Earth on this one! | |
|
| | |
Katana-RN
1st Year
Regist. date : 2007-08-14
Number of posts : 257
Age : 38
Location : Mid West of U.S.A
Real First Name : Katana
Warning :
House : Ravenclaw ;)
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Tue Aug 14 2007, 17:53 | |
| Prince Legolas is just cute. I mean, Orlando Bloom...hello! lol
Arwen is better skilled with her bow. So, Middle Earth has my vote. | |
|
| | |
dragonweaver
2nd Year
Regist. date : 2007-06-22
Number of posts : 2895
Location : on the moon
Real First Name : Ingrid
Warning :
House : Hufflepuff
Wand : Ash and Phoenix Tail Feather
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Wed Aug 15 2007, 00:50 | |
| both *jumps up* i mean you have to love them both.. | |
|
| | |
cookiemonster
1st Year
Regist. date : 2006-02-22
Number of posts : 3086
Age : 31
Location : your mom's house.
Warning :
House : Huffieeee
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Wed Aug 15 2007, 12:00 | |
| I went with Narnia  I dunno, Middle Earth seems so much darker and Narnia is so magical and bright and lovely and awesome And the books are nicer reads than LotR SO yeah. hehe. | |
|
| | |
Ellemanae
1st Year
Country : 
Regist. date : 2007-06-04
Number of posts : 996
Age : 42
Real First Name : Chelle
Warning :
House : Hufflepuff
Crest : 
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Fri Aug 17 2007, 16:35 | |
| I have to say both as they are both amazing stories | |
|
| | |
Bella Muerte
1st Year
Regist. date : 2007-08-09
Number of posts : 996
Location : Florida
Real First Name : Jordanna
Warning :
House : Hufflepuff
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Fri Aug 17 2007, 17:46 | |
| | |
|
| | |
magicguy93
1st Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2007-02-11
Number of posts : 6766
Age : 31
Location : Trying to escape from the insane asylum that I call school.
Real First Name : Chris
Warning :
House : GRYFFINDOR BUT RAVENCLAW AT HEART
Crest : 
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Tue Aug 21 2007, 19:03 | |
| | |
|
| | |
polly
3rd Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2006-03-12
Number of posts : 10718
Age : 32
Location : England
Real First Name : Polly
Warning :
House : Ravenclaw!
Crest :
Wand : Hawthorn and Phoenix Tail Feather
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Wed Aug 22 2007, 03:37 | |
| I put naria for the same reasons as cookie really. | |
|
| | |
WytchKitty
1st Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2006-02-24
Number of posts : 1993
Age : 47
Location : Curled up on any piece of furniture that I want!
Real First Name : Tiff
Warning :
House : Slytherin
Crest : 
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Wed Aug 22 2007, 17:49 | |
| I couldn't resist and I picked LoTR | |
|
| | |
Samantha Granger
1st Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2007-08-20
Number of posts : 10257
Location : Exploring the galaxy in my Leviathan
Real First Name : Jayme
Warning :
House : Gryffindor!!!!
Crest :
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Wed Sep 05 2007, 21:39 | |
| Narnia...I like LOtRs but I would rather be a part of Narnia, hands down | |
|
| | |
Elana
5th Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2006-04-16
Number of posts : 7562
Age : 32
Location : Ra-Ra-Ra-Raaaaavenclaw Tower
Real First Name : Elana
Warning :
House : RAVENCLAW!
Crest :
Wand : Willow and Unicorn Tail Hair
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Fri Sep 07 2007, 22:34 | |
| WOOOO LOTR!!!
*huggles the books...and movies* | |
|
| | |
Puppet_Master
1st Year
Country : 
Regist. date : 2007-01-25
Number of posts : 639
Age : 38
Location : Ireland
Real First Name : Chelle
Warning :
House : Ravenclaw
Crest :
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Tue Sep 11 2007, 05:55 | |
| For me personally it has to be LOTR. LOTR is generally a more adult, complex series and for myself it provides more enjoyable reading. Don't get me wrong, I like the Narnia series. I just believe that LOTR surpasses Narnia in the enjoyment stakes. | |
|
| | |
kikso
1st Year
Regist. date : 2006-04-30
Number of posts : 1007
Age : 35
Location : Egypt
Real First Name : Christiane
Warning :
House : Hufflepuff
Crest :
Wand : Walnut and Unicorn Tail Hair
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Wed Sep 19 2007, 07:26 | |
| I didnt see Middle Earth
but i looove Narnia,so i chose Narnia | |
|
| | |
stephy
Head Girl : 5th Year : Death Eater
Country :
Regist. date : 2006-06-03
Number of posts : 30328
Age : 34
Location : At the Cullen's house stealing Jasper
Real First Name : Stephanie, Polly calls me Stephums, Kim calls me Steffie and among others Im either mommy or granny
Warning :
House : ravenclaw
Crest :
Wand : Walnut & Phoenix Tail Feather
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Sat Sep 22 2007, 22:13 | |
| i voted for J.R.R. Tolkien and Middle-earth... i like this more than the other one.... | |
|
| | |
Rockheart
1st Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2007-09-15
Number of posts : 1990
Age : 45
Location : I am a figment of my own imagination...
Real First Name : Shard
Warning :
House : Slytherin
Crest :
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| |
| | |
drkangelcat
2nd Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2007-02-01
Number of posts : 4340
Age : 32
Location : In la la land.
Real First Name : Cat
Warning :
House : Slytherin's Official Nut
Crest :
Wand : Willow & Veela Hair
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Sat Oct 13 2007, 23:01 | |
| Lol though I love Lord of the Rings....I tend to fall asleep through it....so I picked Narnia lol | |
|
| | |
Dancingsunset
1st Year
Regist. date : 2006-08-03
Number of posts : 8545
Age : 31
Location : Stuck in Octoberland with my amazing husband Anthony
Real First Name : Schizo-Dani and Eryn
Warning :
House : Hufflepuff don't judge us we're still badgers grrr...
Crest :
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Thu Nov 15 2007, 21:41 | |
| | |
|
| | |
ginnyunited
1st Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2007-10-14
Number of posts : 5673
Age : 29
Location : Helping Alice plan Bella's Wedding!
Real First Name : Cassandra (aka. Cassie, Casey, Cass, Case)
Warning :
House : Gryffindor
Crest :
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Sun Dec 09 2007, 13:42 | |
| I CAN'T STAND NARNIA because i was in the school play and it turned out to be SOOOOOOOOOOO bad and SOOOOO embarrasing!  I had to be a dancing reindeer!  AHHHH! I luv lotr tho! | |
|
| | |
hppamela
5th Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2007-11-04
Number of posts : 5190
Age : 41
Location : Valparaiso, In
Real First Name : Pamela
Warning :
House : Gryffie Lion--Hear my roar!
Crest :
Wand : Holly and Phoenix Tail Feather
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Tue Dec 25 2007, 16:58 | |
| I think that Middle Earth is definitely the better of the two worlds. | |
|
| | |
SlytherinPride7
1st Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2007-10-06
Number of posts : 2847
Location : Eating myself, because yes banana's taste GOOD xD
Real First Name : Kaylee
Warning :
House : Slytherin - The Banana In The Muffin :)
Crest :
Wand : Yew & Dragon Heartstring
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Tue Mar 25 2008, 00:33 | |
| *notices how late she is*
Oh well I say Narnia For The Win - Middle earth was pretty cool, but Narnia is just well it has lots of cool stuff - to much for me to even sit here and try to mention. *hides behind something large* Plus I never really liked lotr all that much *please don't shoot* | |
|
| | |
Blue Rabbit Babe
2nd Year
Country : 
Regist. date : 2008-02-25
Number of posts : 3313
Age : 29
Location : Tipton, England. Often Reading, as I am Now
Real First Name : Zoe
Warning :
House : Ravenclaw, YEAH!!
Crest :
Wand : Oak and Phoenix Tail Feathe
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Wed Mar 26 2008, 13:50 | |
| | |
|
| | |
ag167
1st Year
Country : 
Regist. date : 2007-08-04
Number of posts : 7642
Age : 29
Location : England
Real First Name : Amy (AG)
Warning :
House : Slytherin
Crest :
Wand : Holly and Phoenix Tail Feather
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Mon Mar 31 2008, 03:34 | |
| I like Lord of the Rings better, i think the storyline is more compliated and the characters are better
~AG
| |
|
| | |
harryrokz3
1st Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2009-05-17
Number of posts : 844
Age : 27
Location : My imagination. (It's so nice in here!)
Real First Name : Ian
Warning :
House : Hufflepuff!!!
Crest :
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Wed Jul 22 2009, 09:41 | |
| | |
|
| | |
veritaserumgrl773
1st Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2009-07-22
Number of posts : 1332
Age : 29
Location : Music... bootcamp... going...crazy. Can't. finish. *twitch*
Real First Name : Kat
Warning :
House : Ravenclaw
Crest :
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Thu Jul 23 2009, 10:22 | |
| Middle-Earth...Legolassssss! xDDD
Not to mention how I just love the casting in LOTR and i thought Narnia's could have been better...though I do love Ben Barnes as Caspian xD
xxKat | |
|
| | |
geordie_lass43
1st Year
Country :
Regist. date : 2007-07-18
Number of posts : 360
Age : 31
Location : Up On The Clouds :)
Real First Name : Kaytie
Warning :
House : Hufflepuff
Crest :
Wand : Exam not taken
Award Bar :
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth Fri Aug 07 2009, 16:21 | |
| I Couldn't Decide I Like Both *Shrugs* | |
|
| | |
Sponsored content
| | Subject: Re: Narnia vs. Middle-earth | |
| |
|
| | |
| | Narnia vs. Middle-earth | |
|
