Ginny! Good or bad? CLOSED

A controversial debate on whether you agree with the anti-ginny discussions or not!

Sign up here for the debate. Please put your name and house name.

You can NOT choose which side you will be on.

the first two members from each house will be selected for the debate, and a new post opened for them to begin their debate. There will be one person from each house on either side of the debate.

sides:
For: For Ginny

Against: Anti Ginny

please read the announcement within this debate forum. As soon as the two people from each house has signed up, the debate will start!

Ravenclaw - kitkat and Life is 42
hufflepuff - Just_Ginny and Dancingsunset
Slytherin - romance lover and Severus Snape
Gryffindor - WaterLily

Amy's edit: I have removed myself from this debate, as I am now in charge of marking them.

*signs up*

This is one thing I can talk about! (as long as you put me on the side of ginny being good! Pleeeeassseee!)

:cheers:

I'll do this one!!! And I swear I'll talk this time but I will talk!! I went away from the weekend last time... eheh.

ME TOO!!!!!!!! For gryffindor...I will be great if I have to argue that she is good...

But if I have to argue otherwise, I will be distraught and apologise on every post!!!!!

I'll have a go for the ravens

Oh This is sooo the debate for me

Name:romance lover
House: Slytherin

I''ll sign up for slytherins

i'll sign up for ravenclaw

Just awaiting one more hufflepuff and then the debate can begin!

I guess I'l try it out! Sign me up for Hufflepuff!!!!

I try I totally want to at least. PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!

sunset

*steps up to the podium*

Many people have fallen for the the charm and beauty of Ginny Weasley, but there is the undying question. Is this beauty evil.. or is she good?

To the average Harry Potter reader the Gryffindor witch is good. Joined in with the light side. But to the careful reader you should noatice the many things that Ginny Weasley has done that are very immoral.

Ginny Weasley is the cause of the worst kind of pain that can be inflicted on anyone. The only thing that could be worse than a crucio.. is a broken heart, and thats what this Gryffindor princess is good at. She dates and dates breaking the many hearts of the Gryffindor boy's hearts. Next is Harrys. Shes going to break his heart and leave him vulerable for the dark lord.

Ginny Weasley is also very gifted with the wand. Her Bat Bogey hex is not imfamouse around the school. She has power, and where do I ask you think this power comes from? It obviously dose not come from the family she is in. But it comes from the fact Voldemort has possesed her.

To be Possessed by the Dark Lord makes you vunerable to him. He knows your deepest secrets as of that moment. He can use them against you, but he wont because once youve been possesed by the Dark Lord youre left with an emptieness once he is outside of you. You crave for it. For him. The Dark Lord. (ok so all this is just an assumption oh well get over it)

Dancing sets up to stand across for Romance.

Ginny is a witch of power yes, that some maybe believe is evil. But she truly is a good person.

She has made mistakes, many of them, but who doesn't. She's a person. And all people make mistakes. yes most of mistakes are bad but not fatal, not terribly bad. Which make her a good person. To the skilled reader you see that most of Ginny's mistakes lead to a good outcome.

She is gifted, but that to is a good thing. For then she can help win the battle against Voldmort. And if I recall It was HARRY not GINNY that broke them up.

((Wasnt this debate supposed to end on the 27th? hmm?? I was looking forward to mass housepoints for being the only one who posted! so unfair!))


*Jess rolls her eyes at Dancing*

You seem to repeat over and over Dancing that people make mistakes. Which is true but the mistakes Ginny Weasley has made have been fatal to the good side in this war. You do not think it was fatal that Harry Potter went into the chamber of secrets almost dying to try to save Miss. weasley? You do not think scaring the hearts of poor gryffindor boys is Fatal? I ask you what in your opinion is fatal then? And as most Harry Potter readers know this Harry/Ginny romance is yet to be completley over. And whos to say Ginnys not out for revenge against Harry Potter? I ask you this, How many mistakes can one make before there truely considered evil? If voldemort himself walked up to me today and said Im sorry for all the 'mistakes' Ive made.. would he still be evil? You cant treat whats happened as only mistakes. or else no one would be evil.

As this debate has been open for quite some time, I am now going to close it. It was a pity to see that so few of you posted.

However, well done to those who participated. Your points are as follows:

RAVENCLAW

kitkat: didn't post
Life is 42: didn't post

GRYFFINDOR

WaterLily: didn't post

SLYTHERIN

Severus Snape: didn't post
romance lover: 50

HUFFLEPUFF

Dancingsunset: 50
Just_Ginny: didn't post