Harry a Squib?

I found this theory on another site. What do you think about it?

Quote :

I think Harry is a squib if you think about it for a moment it makes sense.
I believe that because he was attacked before he could show any magical talent that the dark lords power that has transfered to him is all that he has.
At the end of book seven when Voldermort is defeated Harrys powers will also fade and the last words will be an ordinary boy with a strange scar.
I think this is more than possible anybody who thinks they can take this further lets see you.
I didn't say he got all of LV's powers i said he got some which would make him average.
And a scar is a physical injury so it might not fade at all and all of you who say you would be mad at that ending would be happy if both LV & harry died would you

I thought this was silly at first, and i still dismiss it but actually i am considering it! some points are pretty good

*snorts* i'm not even going to commment except for one thing, i hope both Harry and Voldielocks die at the end of book 7.

I'm sorry but that theory is so ludicriss i'd rather believe the Snape was bad then Harry being a squib.

I agree with etta, sorry hannah. I just cant see JK Rowling writing the whole series of books just to reveal, well actually harry isnt a proper wizard anyway. It would be like saying it is all a dream and that would ruin the whole vast story

Im sorry - i agree with the two before me. Harry can no way be a squib that would be too...stupid!

And I'll be another to agree. I think this theory is silly. sorry

This theory does seem a bit far-fetched...

To add - if this actually came about it would make a lot of people very angry and i doubt JK would do that

I don't think it's possible for harry to be a squib, but might it be possible that harry's abilities were supposed to be the same as neville's, because harry and neville are extremely similar. Both had extraordinary parents, and both could have been chosen to forfill the prophacy, it was Voldomort that actually chose Harry. Just a random idea...

are you saying that harrys powers have been enhanced by what happened with voldemort when harry was a baby?

I really don't agree. SORRY! it's just not very good. First of all, theres a book that records all the wizards born at MoM and then McGonagall writes letters to them accepting them into Hogwarts. Its really well almost impossible.

Harry is an extroidinarily talented wizard. If he had only Voldemort's powers he would be dark and evil. He has talents Voldemort wouldn't have such as flying and being able to defend himself against dark creatures. He was and will be a great wizard. The only thing I can see that he got from Voldemort is the ability to speak parceltongue and being able to see through Voldemorts eyes and feeling his thoughts. Harry would have turned into a Tom Riddle junior had he not had his own very special magical powers.

How did this ridicouls theory come about anyway?

O this is such a silly theory lol! no Harry will not become a squib and for once I can say that I 100% sure it is not a possibility like someone else mentioned its like saying and it was all a dream.....It just would not make sense.