BIMS - Round 1 - Harry Potter Grumpies - VOTING

Round 1 - Harry Potter Grumpies

Welcome to the first round of Best Icon Maker Standing! As with all of the rounds in this competition, you are making only one icon, using the images provided below (pick one).

Rules:
-Create an icon using ONLY the image provided. Add no other images.
-You may add your own text, textures, colouring, brushes or patterns.
-Be as creative as possible.
-Icon must be 100x100 in size (including any borders!)
-No animation.

You have one month to send your icons to me by PM. Please upload them to
an image host which will not identify you, such as imageshack, tinypic
or servimg (not photobucket).

Round One: Harry Potter Grumpies





(click in the images to enlarge)

Good luck everyon!

Vote From Amongst the Following
Use the following format:

Quote :

eg. Positive Vote: Icon B, because the texture used was great.
Positive Vote: Icon J, because the font worked really well.
Negative Vote: Icon H, because the picture was too grainy.

1		2		3
4		5		6		7

Positive Vote: #3 because it made me laugh out loud, and seems like exactly something that old sourpuss would say

Positive Vote: #6 The text made me laugh and I like the colors.

Negative Vote: #7 It's kind of washed-out

Re-Voted

Positive Vote: Icon #5 - Nice blend.

Positive Vote: Icon #6 - I love how he appeared to be covered with moss to me. xD

Negative Vote: Icon #1 - Just because I don't think the size is right and nothing seemed to be changed nor enhanced with the photo.

Re-voted

Pos: #6 - Very funny, the pic lends itself to the text well.

Pos: #5 - I like the colour. It's flashy!

Neg: #1 - doesn't seem like a lot has been done to the picture other than the (very small) text added...

Re-voted

Postive Vote: Icon # 6 - It's funny and the colors are great.
Positive Vote: Icon # 5 - The color mixtures is great. It's simple but flashy.
Negative Vote: Icon # 1 - The size doesn't really fit for an icon.

Re-Voted

Pos: #5 - I love the way you edited the colors. Awesome blend.

Pos: #6 - I like the editing of the colors and the quote as well.

Neg: #1 - The size looks a little small for an icon and besides the text it doesn't really look like much editing has been done to the photo.

Re-voted

Positive vote: #5 - Flawless colouring, always a safe choice.
Positive vote: #4 - The sharpening here actually worked somehow and there were some thought put into the text so I'm going to reward the effort.

Negative vote: #1 - The size simply is not what it should be.

Re-voted.

Positive vote: #4 I love Snape and the coloring it has on it

Positive vote: #6 The quote is funny

Negative vote: #1 No coloring, the quote is to hard to read, and it's not even the right size.

Positive Vote: #6 Text made me giggle and the coloring is well done.
Positive Vote: #4 The text is simple, but straight to the point. Coloring is muy bueno.
Negative Vote:#2 I just think it's over contrasted, and the font isn't very pretty to look at.

Positive Vote 5: Really nice work. Simple, but beautiful.
Positive Vote 4: I think it just worked really nicely. Well done with just the right amount of text.

Negative Vote 7: The size is off and it's just not that great of a coloring choice.

Icon	Name	Neg Votes	Pos Votes	Total votes	Housepoints
#6	Raistlin The Wizard	0	8	8	150 25 200 = 375
#5	violetriddle	0	8	8	150 25 200 = 375
#4	amortentia773	0	5	5	150 25 125 = 300
#3	FaerieOfDoom	1	1	0	150 25 0 = 175
#2	Samantha Granger	1	0	-1	150 25-1 = 174
#7	Hermione.Granger	2	0	-2	150 25-2 = 173
#1	stephy	7	0	-7	150-7 = 143

[/font]