BIMS - Round 10 - Could it be magic? - VOTING

Vote From Amongst the Following
Use the following format:

Quote:

eg. Positive Vote: Icon B, because the texture used was great. Positive Vote: Icon J, because the font worked really well. Negative Vote: Icon H, because the picture was too grainy.

1		2		3		4
5		6		7		x	x

Pos: #3 - I love love love the coloring and how it managed to make the picture so much lighter, and the choice and placement of fonts were very well done.

Pos: #7 - I like the cropping that was used (makes it look very mysterious xD) and the texture it awesome.

Neg: #5 - I'm not a fan of the texture...it's a little too forward and distracts from the actual image of the book. If it was more see through and less stand outish it would look really cool.

Positive: Icon 3 - It's a beautifully made icon that just gives the picture a little something extra with the text.
Positive: Icon 6 - Honestly, after three it's the one that I like the most, but I still wouldn't think it amazing.

Negative: Icon 7. I'm not a fan of the cropping or the font that was used on the icon.

Pos: #3 Color. Check. Font/Text. Check. Aka, flawless
Pos: #5 I actually like the texture, comparing with the others it fits, it gives a dust old look.

Neg: #1 Only cuz I think it had the less work put into it.

Positive # 5: I do think that the texture is slightly too strong, however, it makes me feel like I am looking at the book through an old dusty window in the rain. And the book looks magical. It reminds me of The Neverending Story.

Positive # 7: I like the combination of the texture and the fact that he is glowing, it makes him look eerie, and like he is disappearing into some kind of mist. And I like what it says and the way it was cropped.

Negative: # 1: It looks nice and everything, I just find it to be very dull.

Positive #7: It obviously differs from the rest, in the fact that... It's the only one not using the book picture

Positive #4: I like the coloring and stars.

Negative #3: I think it would've been better if the text was aligned differently. I read it as "Magic, Believe in, Do you?"

Pos: 4. It's pretty, I like stars. Very pleasing to look at.

Pos: 7. Because it's true.

Neg: 2. The grey tones are kinda dull for a 'magic' theme.

Positive Vote: Icon 6, because the color and contrast are amazing! I really love how crisp the text it and you did a great job cropping. You could, however, do without the text or do some adjusting to it since it doesn't feel quite right.

Positive Vote: Icon 7, because I like the cropping and editing. I do suggest a different font choice though.

Negative Vote: Icon 2, because the image didn't feel magical. The color seemed too dull, the font awkward, and the cropping wasn't ideal. I did like the choice of words though.

+ Icon 4 it's cute
+ Icon 7 I like it.
- Icon 2 Eh...not that great.

I dunno if this is done already but, here:

Positive vote: Icon #4 - I like how you chose to casually add the stars into the background instead of putting texts. The stars really filled the text's spot to interpret "magic" instead. Very unique, tbh.

Positive vote: Icon #1 - I'm not a fan of the font face but this icon's dimmed-looking blend.

Negative vote: Icon #3 - Though I like the overall look of it, the typography isn't agreeable. The choice of fonts are fine, but the placements are rather confusing. You could have reasons why you placed them like this, but, generally speaking, since humans tend to read off from top to bottom horizontally this placement isn't a good one.