BIMS - Round 3 - Harry Potter Redheads - VOTING

Round 3 - Harry Potter Redheads

Welcome to the third round of Best Icon Maker Standing! As with all of the rounds in this competition, you are making only one icon, using the images provided below (pick one).

Rules:
-Create an icon using ONLY the image provided. Add no other images.
-You may add your own text, textures, colouring, brushes or patterns.
-Be as creative as possible.
-Icon must be 100x100 in size (including any borders!)
-No animation.

You have one month to send your icons to me by PM. Please upload them to
an image host which will not identify you, such as imageshack, tinypic
or servimg (not photobucket).

Round Three: Harry Potter Redheads





(click in the images to enlarge)

Good luck everyon!

Vote From Amongst the Following
Use the following format:

Quote :

eg. Positive Vote: Icon B, because the texture used was great.
Positive Vote: Icon J, because the font worked really well.
Negative Vote: Icon H, because the picture was too grainy.

1		2		3
4		5		6

Positive Vote: #1 because it is amazing and made me laugh. The text goes perfectly with Ginny's smirk and I like the color negative-looking overlay used

Positive Vote: #4 becasue the way the color was altered really highlights their red hair

Negative Vote: #5 because though I love the twins, I don't like the fuzzy font

Positive Vote: Icon #4 - I love how the colors were blended. Simple but stands out.
+ uber filled with brother love

Positive Vote: Icon #1 - Simply because it's a Harmony avie! xD Naaw. The color's good plus the text went really well with the photo.

Negative Vote: Icon #5 - It could've looked better if you did some tricks that wouldn't make the photos seemed to be in a too "really not in here" way. Maybe next time try to play with textures or other blends? Then, try using other fonts that aren't plain-looking or non-matching like that one. I suggest download handwriting-looking fonts and some simple serif'd ones.

Pos: #1 - Nice text, very clever.

Pos: #2 - Despite the not-so-great quality of the picture, I really like the text, so I'm giving it a bonus.

Neg: #5 - the background and text threw me off.

Re-voted

Positive Vote: # 1 - I really like the mixture of colors and the text. It really fits with Ginny's picture.
Positive Vote: # 4 - The blending of colors are really great. It's simple but I really like it.
Negative Vote: # 5 -The text doesn't really fit with the picture. I mean the font.

Pos: #1 - I love love love the way this was edited! It looks great and it's pretty. xD

Pos: #4 - It's simple but the colors are blended very well and there's lots of brother love going on

Neg: #5 - I don't quite like the background and the text is a bit fuzzy. A clearer image and some more color editing may have been nice.

Re-voted

Positive vote: #3 - Well... it's just not as bad as some of the others xD I wish there was a bir more effort in it though.

Positive vote: #4 - It looks good, but lazy, some text would have been nice since this is an Avatar's tourny text would make it more interesting, as it is looks like a good avy of a set.

Negative vote: #5 - The size...

Re-voted.

Positive vote: #1 I love the color and how the smirk just fits the quote.

Positive vote: #3 It could be better, but the dark coloring looks ok

Negative vote: #5 I hate the blurriness of it and how.....wrong the size is. It doesn't look that different, except the background.

Positive Vote: #1, because it is just all together amazing. the font and text matches the picture AND the coloring is good.
Positive Vote: #4 Because the coloring is nice... and I love the cheesy grins.
Negative Vote: #3 Because the gingerness isn't embraced what so ever. Made me sad.

Positive Vote 4: Absolutely gorgeous coloring. What an icon should be, pretty and simple.

Positive Vote 3: Good icon and with a dislike of the Weasleys it's difficult for me to say so. Still, nice job.

Negative Vote 2: The quality of the picture is what kills it for me. The text was good, well placed and everything. If it weren't for the fact that the picture was in bad shape, it'd have been really great.

Icon	Name	Neg Votes	Pos Votes	Total votes	Housepoints
#1	Raistlin The Wizard	0	7	7	150 25 175 = 350
#4	violetriddle	1	8	1	150 25 175 = 350
#2	amortentia773	1	3	2	150 25 50 = 225
#3	FaerieOfDoom	1	3	2	150 25 50 = 225
#6	Hermione.Granger	0	1	1	150 25 25 = 200
#5	stephy	8	0	-8	150-8 = 142
-	-	-	-	-	-

As
you can see, the table presents how many positive and negative votes
you had, the total votes which is the positive votes minus the negatives
votes and it's the number that will be used to the overall standings
and to find the winner at the end of the tournament.

There's
a column for the housepoints you won in this round, the total of points
is made of participating points, voting points and votes points (25
points per total votes column).

Points for voting:

Clafin - 25
Sashi - 25
Elfie Dumbledore - 25
amberg93 - 25
MarieC - 25
Samantha Granger - 25