BIMS - Round 4 - It's In This Kiss - Voting

Please read how the voting works:

-In the following post, I will create a table with all the submitted icons.

-You then need to name three icons in your post: you must give two icons a positive vote, and one icon a negative vote.
You should also give a reason why - commenting on an aspect of the icon
you liked (for the positive votes) and what you felt could be better
(for the negative vote). This is to help icon makers in further rounds.

Quote:

eg. Positive Vote: Icon B, because the texture used was great. Positive Vote: Icon J, because the font worked really well. Negative Vote: Icon H, because the picture was too grainy.

-Both
participants and non-participants can vote. Non-participants get 50
points for voting but participants are penalized for not voting.. Voting
will stay open for around a month.

-Participants CANNOT vote for their own icon.

-Please compare the icons to the original pictures before you vote. Many times you will say nothing is done because someone didn't change the image in a huge way, but a closer look will show you that they did.

Vote From Amongst the Following
Use the following format:

Quote:

eg. Positive Vote: Icon B, because the texture used was great. Positive Vote: Icon J, because the font worked really well. Negative Vote: Icon H, because the picture was too grainy.

1		2		3
4		5		6

Pos #1 - 5: Not a fan of the colouring and cropping but I had pos someone one...
Post #2 - 2: Hate the couple, hate the frame and hate the fadeness but there's work put into this icon which i cant' ignore when compared to the rest.

Neg 3 - The colour of the font? What were you thinking it clashes so much! And why is the man a clear shade of flesh and woman turnign bluish???

REVOTED

Pos: 1 - Really like the coloring, good cropping, and loooove the faded quality, especially at the bottom!
Pos: 2 - Though I don't like picture frame here and think the fade is a little too much, like Rai said, this one looks like it had the most work put into it out of the others.

Neg: 3 - Gonna have to agree with Rai again...the font and color is hard to read and the coloring doesn't seem consistant or go very well.

Revoted

Positive: 1- I think the contrast might be a tad high, but I like the faded quality and the cropping.

Positive: 4- I really like the coloring and the cropping. I think the coloring of this is much better than the original, it really makes the couple pop.

Negative: 3- The lady looks ill because of the coloring, and the font/color combination is hard to read.

revoted

Positive: Icon 5, because the coloring was awesome and not the traditional and kinda boring ones that you see everywhere. It was something different and that's awesome.
Positive: Icon 4, because I like it better than icon 1.

Negative: Icon 3, there isn't much I can say that hasn't been said already.

Re-voted

Positive for #1: it looks so adorable. Especially with the coloring and the light texture. *o*

Positive for #6: Simple cropping and lovely coloring.

Negative for #3: I don't think the text matches the coloring, and the coloring makes them look like...zombies? Or beaten or something. Too purplish.