okay i'm not sure HOW reliable al this is since its from imdb and sorry if someone has already posted this!
okay here we go, lots of copying and pasting
forgive me if it doesnt make much sense since the poster was replying to questions but i'll try and keep it as readable as possible.
THEY TOOK OUT THE SPINNING ROOM AND ALL THE COOL ROOMS IN TEH DEPARTMENT OF MYSTERIES! They only left the Hall of Prophecies and the room with the veil.
-Luna is PERFECT, but not in it enough. Her best scene has to be when she is feeding the thestrals.
-The farewell scene is great (although it comes off as more of a prank then them actually quitting school). The best line from all the books ("Give 'em hell for us, Peeves") had to be cut since they never introduce the ghost in all the movies. The scene really is great, though.
-They defintiely have it and it is really cool. Actually, all the stuff with Harry's visions (all the Occlumency in general) is really well-done.
BEST SHOT IN THE MOVIE: When Voldemort gets in Harry's head at one point they show an actual scene from the first movie (Mirror of Erised) and Voldemort walks in it. It is very, very cool.
-there wasn't a scene with Lucius at home in the entire movie. Lucius is in it more than any other movie, but his scenes are all contained within the Department of Mysteries (Harry sees him before his hearing and during the final battle).
The scene with the masks is awesome ... and creepy! When Harry and the gang are standing in the middle of the Hall of Prophecies the Death Eaters start to slowly come out of the darkness with their masks on. It is really cool looking.
-Yeah, I thought there would be waterfalls as well around Azkaban, but in the final movie it is just in the middle of the ocean. It looks great, though.
-Hagrid is not sacked in the movie, but Trelawney is.
-This is my biggest disappointment. The final battle in the Ministry of Magic is really good, but it isn't long enough. They only feature three rooms: the Atrium, the Hall of Prophecies, and the room with the veil. The spinning room is not even in it.
The whole scene felt too quick. I wanted there to be more of a sense of exploring and, during the final battle with all the Death Eaters (although it is still cool) I wanted there to be more running around through the Department rather than just standing around shooting wands.
-It is hard to count, but I would say there are about six or seven Death Eaters (including Lucuis and Bellatrix).
-The special effects are great and, about the orbs, ALL of them are destroyed (pretty cool scene).
-The veil battle was, as mentioned before, cool, but it just seemed to quick. The battle pretty much only involved Lucuis, Sirius, and Bellatrix. Also, they never really explain the veil at all. If someone hasn't read the book I cannot see them understanding what is going on ...
I have to reiterate, though, that it was still super cool! It just was a little short ...
-The entrance to the Hall of Prophecies just looks really cool. Great art direction. The room is all shiny black with, like, these bluish, sleek lines criss-crossing throughout.
-The whole final battle lasts about 10 minutes, at the most. It is weird: they land in London on the thestrals, go down the phone booth elevator, and are all of a sudden in the Hall of Prophecies. It is very jarring. But again, I guess they had to do that to save time. A bummer, though.
when asked about the trio and friends falling in the vieled room:
-Yeah, I still don't understand that part. I think they don't hit the ground because of some weird magic in the room with the veil, but they never really explain it.
-This movie, weirdly enough, reminding of the first two movies. A lot of the feelings of being introduced to a magical world are back since you get to see some things for the first time (the Ministry of Magic, Grawp, 11 Grimauld Place, etc.).
-I was disappionted in how little screen-time some of my favorite characters had. I know it had to be done, but people like Tonks and Luna are only in a few scenes.
-I was very surprised by how AMAZING Umbridge was -- seriously, she steals the movie!
- Some of the scenes were perfectly molded from the book
- be prepared, they take out A LOT of stuff. Seriously, a lot.
-The kiss scene is really nicely done. The mistletoe is even in it!
- The Harry/Cho bad date in Hogmeade was completely cut.
-Oh yeah! The scene where Mr. Weasley is attacked by the snake is one of the best scenes in the movie. They do a really great job with it. It is all shot from the perspective of the sanke and is really cool.
Ginny is great, but not in it enough.
The stuff the director added with her liking Harry (and being jealous of teh Cho/Harry thing), though, is PERFECT. A very welcome addition. The best thing with Ginny, though, is that they hint a lot about her and Harry getting together. Especially during the scene when Harry and Cho stay behind in the Room of Requirement to "talk." Ginny looks heartbroken.
A LOT was taken out, be prepared. I can't list it all, but here is some key stuff that got the boot:
-No quidditch at all in the whole movie.
-No house-elves (except Kreacher -- he is in it)
-No Rita Skeeter.
-The Quibbler is seen, but never mentioned.
-Mrs. Black's portrait is heard and seen for a second, but never talked about.
-Sirius does not give Harry the mirror.
-No Brain Room or any other rooms in the Department of Mysteries besides the Hall of Prophecies and the room with the veil.
Tons of other stuff was taken out, but I don't have time to type it all. Ha ha.
THE DUMBLOEDORE/VOLDEMORT DUEL IS THE GREATEST THING IN ALL THE MOVIES COMPBINED! Seriously, they even make it better than the book. It is awesome and worth it just for that!
Actually (and this will spoil it for everyone, since it is different from the book -- don't read below if you don't want to know) ...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
Cho is the one who rats out Dumbedore's Army. That is why Harry breaks up with her.
The good news, though, you find out at the end that Umbridge used some Veritaserum on her and that is why she revealed her secret.
there isn't a scene where Ron says "I love you" to Hermione. But the flirtation between them in this movie is GREAT!
There is a scene where Ron gets an ugly sweater from his Mom for Christmas. When he holds it up to himself he has a look of horror on his face because it is so unflattering. While everyone is laughing Hermione gives him the cutest little smile that shows how cute she thinks he is. It is a priceless scene.
Ahhhhhhh, the prophecy. Are you ready for this? They don't really explain it that much at all. I mean, don't freak out, they definitely do a little ... but as a non-reader I have NO idea how you will understand its importance. Maybe it is because I am huge fan of the books, but I feel like they kind of gloss over it (they don't even mention Snape overhearing it or Trelawney being the one that speaks it).
-Like a knife through the heart, one of my favorite characters in all the books, Lupin is barely in it AT ALL. Only a few scenes and he barely speaks.
-Yeah, Bellatrix (while PERFECT) only has a few lines. I must say, though, when she chants "I killed Sirius Black!" as she runs away like a coward ... it is really creepy.
-I am not sure what flashback scene you are talking about -- Snape's Worst Memory? If it is that one, it is pretty good. Short, but effective. It is interesting becasue they present in a different way than in a pensive. That was cool. Thing that bummed me out, though? No Lily!
6 centaurs fight with Grawp
Question from a imdb poster: "I have one question about Ron and Hermione. In the test sceenings people said there was a scene in the DA where Hermione blows Ron back with a spell, is this still in the movie? Thanks in advance!"
the REPLY!: Yeah, that's in there -- and it's hilarious. Ron is trying to show off in front of this friends. Fred and George actaully make a bet about how long it will take for Hermione to beat him. It's great. And when Hermione wins, she walks away, giggling with her girlfriends.
Ron's response after being defeated: "I let her do that."
Ha ha. Great.
thats all for now folks. if you wanna read all 16 pages of questions and asnwers for yourself, here is the linkie:
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0373889/board/thread/75752702?p=1