Chapter 19

Admin

Deputy Head

Subject: Chapter 19 Fri Jul 20 2007, 08:45

Chapter Nineteen - The Silver Doe

Use this thread to discuss the events in Chapter 19 of Deathly Hallows.

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Sat Jul 21 2007, 02:16

I loved this chapter! I saw the chapter title, and thought that perhaps the "doe" referred to would have something to do with Lily. And then a little later in the book I guessed what the exact connection was.

I loved Ron's return and him rescuing Harry from the pond, and also the scene that followed - Ron's insecurities made real; Harry and Hermione being together was the one thing he feared most would happen, and then Harry tells him he loves Hermione like a sister, yay!

Hehe, the R/Hr shipper in me was squeeing in this chapter!

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Sun Jul 22 2007, 09:14

That chapter was great and I am glad it was Ron that stabbed the horcrux instead of getting Harry to do everything lol! It made me squee to I mean it was so cute Rons fear was Hermione being in love with Harry.

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Sun Jul 22 2007, 14:23

I loved this whole chapter too. The silver doe just kept going round and round in my mind, its funny, really, I should have realised who's it might have been, though it was totally different to what I had expected of him.

I love Ron's whole return, and all my annoyance of him vanished. I thought that him being the one to destroy the horcrux was great too. It also explained part of why Ron acted the way he did, which was brilliant.

Hermione really over reacted when they arrived back at the tent, but I can see why - she was worried about the person she loved and I can understand her anger to a degree too.

The introduction of the Snatchers was interesting and reminded me once again of Hitlers 'army'

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Wed Aug 15 2007, 20:34

I loved this chapter... i couldnt really figure out who cast the doe and i couldnt make a connection... and i loved that fact that Ron came back and saved Harry. Boy was Harry lucky..lol... and then Hermione tried to cause him great pain..i laughed lol

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Wed Aug 15 2007, 20:36

Yeah I loved this chapter. When I read about the doe I was kind of confussed. I didn't know who sent it.

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Thu Aug 16 2007, 20:08

Me too... i was thinking that it might have been Harry's dad but then I thought that his was a stag so it would of had horns and also i thought that he was dead so that there was no way it could have been his

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Thu Aug 16 2007, 20:10

I thought it was Lily. And I thought it was Dumbledore, I don't know why though.

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Thu Aug 16 2007, 21:54

I never knew lily's was a doe so thats why i didnt think it was hers. and i think that you thought that it was dumbledore because you like many others didnt want to believe that he was dead

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Fri Aug 17 2007, 16:36

Well I knew he was dead but I thought that he miht have sent it from the dead, because he is.. I mean was the most powerful wizard of the world. I didn't want him to be dead.

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Fri Aug 17 2007, 20:40

I get what you are saying but I dont think that it is possible to do that

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Fri Aug 17 2007, 21:11

I know. I just thought that it was Dumbledore even though his patronus was a phoenix but I thought it changed and all that.

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Thu Dec 27 2007, 22:48

I dont think taht his patronus is ever gonna change.... if it did could you imagine what it would be...

Subject: Re: Chapter 19 Sat Jan 12 2008, 10:31

When I read this I really didn't think of Lily. I was like why are you fallowing it stupid the whole time. I couldn't beleive how dumb that was. When he pulled out of the pond I could of sworn that it was Hermione saving the day again. I was really glad it was Ron though. I couldn't wait to hear ROn's side of the story and to be honest I was surprized when Hermione was mad. Though, it made me smile.

» Chapter 22
» Chapter 6
» Chapter 21
» Chapter 5
» Chapter 20