BIMS - Round 3 - Heart Of Sound - Voting

Please read how the voting works:

-In the following post, I will create a table with all the submitted icons.

-You then need to name three icons in your post: you must give two icons a positive vote, and one icon a negative vote.
You should also give a reason why - commenting on an aspect of the icon
you liked (for the positive votes) and what you felt could be better
(for the negative vote). This is to help icon makers in further rounds.

Quote:

eg. Positive Vote: Icon B, because the texture used was great. Positive Vote: Icon J, because the font worked really well. Negative Vote: Icon H, because the picture was too grainy.

-Both
participants and non-participants can vote. Non-participants get 50
points for voting but participants are penalized for not voting.. Voting
will stay open for around a month.

-Participants CANNOT vote for their own icon.

-Please compare the icons to the original pictures before you vote. Many times you will say nothing is done because someone didn't change the image in a huge way, but a closer look will show you that they did.

Vote From Amongst the Following
Use the following format:

Quote:

eg. Positive Vote: Icon B, because the texture used was great. Positive Vote: Icon J, because the font worked really well. Negative Vote: Icon H, because the picture was too grainy.

1		2		3
4		5		6

Pos #1 - 2: kudos for using the cello i also like the cropping a lot.
Pos #2 - 5: no fair. rubbing animnation in our faces! though i wish the pione was a bit more polished like in icon 3.

Neg - 1: Sorry but it looks kinda rough on the edges...

REVOTED

Pos: 3 - I like the sharpness of the piano, and though I think the background could be faded a tad bit more to make the piano stand out more, overall it's pretty good!
Pos: 4 - Really like the creativity here, that it's just not a piano on a music background and the orange coloring really helps so it's not just black and white.

Neg: 1 - While I like how this is cropped much better than the other, I think the effects outdue the photo and make it look a little too grainy and rough.

Revoted

Positive: 2- I like the cropping, the wording, the font, and the coloring. It is very nicely done!

Positive: 5- Though I don't like the background or the wording, I do really like the music note animation. It works really well for this theme.

Negative: 1- I really like the cropping, but everything else was a bit overdone because the piano is now too dark and blurry.

revoted

Positive Vote: Icon 3, because the icon is really well made and the concept was very well done.
Positive Vote: Icon 6, I'm not really a fan of the texture or the icon in general, but I like it better than the others.

Negative: Icon 1, because although the concept was good, the execution - from the coloring to the grainy quality of the image - was not.

Re-Voted

Positive for #2: At one part I'm sorta biased here, lol, because I love the violin, viola and the cello. XD But anyway, graphic wise, the icon is really good. It came out a bit sharp, but the coloring and the text you added sort of diverts the attention to thurr instead.

Positive for #6: The coloring is lovely.

Negative for #4: Despite the original creativity you got here, I don't think it sells the piano much in this avvie.